Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute, Reston, Virginia.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2019 Jul;16(7):902-907. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2018.11.025. Epub 2019 Jan 22.
Bundled payments have been touted as mechanisms to optimize quality and costs. A recent feasibility study evaluating bundled payments for screening mammography episodes predated widespread adoption of digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT). We explore a similar model reflecting emerging acceptance of DBT in breast cancer screening.
Using 4-year data for 59,094 screening episodes from two large facilities within a large academic health system, we utilized published methodology to calibrate Medicare national allowable reference prices for women undergoing screening mammography before and after practice-wide implementation of DBT.
Excluding DBT, Medicare-normalized bundled prices for traditional breast imaging 364 days downstream to screening mammography are extremely similar pre- and post-DBT implementation ($182.86 in 2013; $182.68 in 2015). The addition of DBT increased a DBT-inclusive bundled price by $53.16 (an amount lower than the $56.13 Medicare allowable fee for screening DBT) but was associated with significantly reduced recall rates (13.0% versus 9.4%; P < .0001). Without or with DBT, screening episode bundled prices remained sensitive to bundle-included services and varied little by patient age, race, or insurance status.
Prior non-DBT approaches to bundled payment models for breast cancer screening remain viable as DBT becomes the standard of care, with bundle prices varying little by patient age, race, or insurance status. Higher DBT-inclusive bundled prices, however, highlight the need to explore societal costs more broadly (eg, reduced time away from work from fewer recalls) as bundled payment models evolve.
捆绑支付被吹捧为优化质量和成本的机制。最近的一项可行性研究评估了针对筛查性乳房 X 光检查的捆绑支付,这一研究早于数字乳腺断层合成术(DBT)的广泛应用。我们探讨了一种类似的模型,反映了 DBT 在乳腺癌筛查中逐渐被接受。
利用来自一个大型学术医疗系统内的两个大型设施的 4 年数据,我们使用了已发表的方法,对在全实践中实施 DBT 前后接受筛查性乳房 X 光检查的女性的 Medicare 国家允许参考价格进行校准。
不包括 DBT,在实施 DBT 前后 364 天传统乳房成像的 Medicare 标准化捆绑价格非常相似(2013 年为 182.86 美元;2015 年为 182.68 美元)。增加 DBT 将包含 DBT 的捆绑价格提高了 53.16 美元(低于 Medicare 为筛查 DBT 允许的 56.13 美元),但与召回率显著降低相关(13.0%对 9.4%;P<0.0001)。有无 DBT,筛查检查的捆绑价格仍然对捆绑所包含的服务敏感,且受患者年龄、种族或保险状况的影响很小。
在 DBT 成为护理标准的情况下,先前非 DBT 方法的用于乳腺癌筛查的捆绑支付模型仍然可行,捆绑价格因患者年龄、种族或保险状况的差异很小。然而,更高的包含 DBT 的捆绑价格凸显了随着捆绑支付模型的发展,更广泛地探讨社会成本(例如,召回率降低导致工作时间减少)的必要性。