Harvard Medical School, Boston, 25 Shattuck St, Boston, MA, 02115, USA.
Institute for Technology Assessment, Massachusetts General Hospital, 101 Merrimac Street, Boston, MA, 02114, USA.
J Neurol. 2019 Mar;266(3):755-765. doi: 10.1007/s00415-019-09199-y. Epub 2019 Jan 25.
To capture ALS progression in arm, leg, speech, swallowing, and breathing segments using a disease-specific staging system, namely tollgate-based ALS staging system (TASS), where tollgates refer to a set of critical clinical events including having slight weakness in arms, needing a wheelchair, needing a feeding tube, etc. METHODS: We compiled a longitudinal dataset from medical records including free-text clinical notes of 514 ALS patients from Mayo Clinic, Rochester-MN. We derived tollgate-based progression pathways of patients up to a 1-year period starting from the first clinic visit. We conducted Kaplan-Meier analyses to estimate the probability of passing each tollgate over time for each functional segment.
At their first clinic visit, 93%, 77%, and 60% of patients displayed some level of limb, bulbar, and breathing weakness, respectively. The proportion of patients at milder tollgate levels (tollgate level < 2) was smaller for arm and leg segments (38% and 46%, respectively) compared to others (> 65%). Patients showed non-uniform TASS pathways, i.e., the likelihood of passing a tollgate differed based on the affected segments at the initial visit. For instance, stratified by impaired segments at the initial visit, patients with limb and breathing impairment were more likely (62%) to use bi-level positive airway pressure device in a year compared to those with bulbar and breathing impairment (26%).
Using TASS, clinicians can inform ALS patients about their individualized likelihood of having critical disabilities and assistive-device needs (e.g., being dependent on wheelchair/ventilation, needing walker/wheelchair or communication devices), and help them better prepare for future.
使用特定于疾病的分期系统(即基于关卡的肌萎缩侧索硬化症分期系统(TASS))来捕捉手臂、腿部、言语、吞咽和呼吸等方面的 ALS 进展,其中关卡是指一系列关键的临床事件,包括手臂出现轻微无力、需要轮椅、需要喂食管等。
我们从 Mayo 诊所罗切斯特明尼苏达州的医疗记录中编制了一个纵向数据集,其中包括 514 名 ALS 患者的自由文本临床记录。我们根据每位患者从首次就诊开始的 1 年时间内的临床记录,推导出基于关卡的进展途径。我们进行了 Kaplan-Meier 分析,以估计每个功能段随时间通过每个关卡的概率。
在首次就诊时,93%、77%和 60%的患者分别显示出一定程度的肢体、延髓和呼吸无力。在较轻的关卡水平(关卡级别<2),手臂和腿部的患者比例较小(分别为 38%和 46%),而其他关卡的患者比例较大(>65%)。患者表现出非均匀的 TASS 途径,即通过关卡的可能性因初始就诊时受影响的节段而异。例如,根据初始就诊时受损的节段分层,有肢体和呼吸障碍的患者在一年内更有可能(62%)使用双水平气道正压通气装置,而有延髓和呼吸障碍的患者则为 26%。
使用 TASS,临床医生可以告知 ALS 患者他们出现严重残疾和辅助设备需求的个体化可能性(例如,依赖轮椅/通气、需要助行器/轮椅或沟通设备),并帮助他们更好地为未来做好准备。