Peltonen Kirsi, Kangaslampi Samuli
Faculty of Social Sciences/Psychology, Tampere University, Tampere, Finland.
Eur J Psychotraumatol. 2019 Jan 17;10(1):1558708. doi: 10.1080/20008198.2018.1558708. eCollection 2019.
: Millions of children and adolescents worldwide suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and other problems due to prolonged exposure to traumatizing events. Forms of cognitive-behavioural therapy are the most commonly used treatment for PTSD, but evidence from sophisticated studies in clinical settings among children is limited. : This multicentre, parallel, non-blinded, pragmatic randomized controlled trial assessed the effectiveness of narrative exposure therapy (NET) in traumatized children and adolescents. Fifty 9-17-year-old participants, who had experienced prolonged traumatic conditions in the form of refugeedom or family violence and suffered from PTSD symptoms, were randomized into NET ( = 29) and treatment as usual (TAU; = 21) active control groups. The objective was to determine whether NET can be feasibly implemented within the existing healthcare system of a high-income country and whether it would reduce mental health problems, especially PTSD, and increase resilience, in children and adolescents with multiple traumas more effectively than TAU. We hypothesized that NET would be more effective than TAU in reducing symptoms and increasing resilience. : Analysis of variance revealed that PTSD and psychological distress, but not depression symptoms, decreased regardless of treatment group. Resilience increased in both groups. Within-group analyses showed that the decrease in PTSD symptoms was significant in the NET group only. The effect sizes were large in NET but small in TAU. Concerning PTSD symptom cut-off scores, the reduction in the share of participants with clinical-level PTSD was significant in the NET group only. Intention-to-treat analyses using linear mixed models confirmed these results. : Despite its shortcomings, this study gives preliminary support for the safety, effectiveness, and usefulness of NET among multiply traumatized children and adolescents in clinical settings. Close attention must be paid to the implementation of the new intervention as an everyday tool in healthcare.
全球数以百万计的儿童和青少年因长期暴露于创伤性事件而患有创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)和其他问题。认知行为疗法是治疗PTSD最常用的方法,但儿童临床环境中复杂研究的证据有限。
这项多中心、平行、非盲、实用随机对照试验评估了叙事暴露疗法(NET)对受创伤儿童和青少年的有效性。50名9至17岁的参与者,他们经历了难民身份或家庭暴力形式的长期创伤状况并患有PTSD症状,被随机分为NET组(n = 29)和常规治疗(TAU;n = 21)活性对照组。目的是确定NET是否可以在高收入国家现有的医疗保健系统中切实可行地实施,以及它是否能比TAU更有效地减少多重创伤儿童和青少年的心理健康问题,尤其是PTSD,并提高恢复力。我们假设NET在减轻症状和提高恢复力方面比TAU更有效。
方差分析显示,无论治疗组如何,PTSD和心理困扰都会减少,但抑郁症状不会减少。两组的恢复力都有所提高。组内分析表明,只有NET组的PTSD症状减少显著。NET组的效应量很大,而TAU组的效应量很小。关于PTSD症状截断分数,只有NET组临床水平PTSD参与者的比例降低显著。使用线性混合模型的意向性分析证实了这些结果。
尽管存在缺点,但这项研究为NET在临床环境中多重创伤儿童和青少年中的安全性、有效性和实用性提供了初步支持。必须密切关注将这种新干预措施作为医疗保健日常工具的实施情况。