Division of Language and Communication Science, School of Health Sciences, City, University of London, London, UK.
Speech Pathology, Faculty of Health Sciences, The University of Sydney, Lidcombe, NSW, Australia.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2019 May;54(3):465-478. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12452. Epub 2019 Jan 28.
Communication impairments are common and pervasive for people a long time following acquired brain injury (ABI). These impairments have a significant impact on a person's quality of life (QOL) post-injury. Project-based treatment is a treatment approach that could have an impact on communication skills and QOL for people with ABI a long-term post-injury. This treatment is embedded in a context of meaningful activities chosen by people with ABI, whereby, as a group, they work collaboratively to achieve a tangible end product.
To evaluate the feasibility and initial efficacy of project-based treatment on improving the communication skills and QOL for people with ABI.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: An exploratory controlled trial with alternate allocation of groups, and follow-up at 6-8 weeks, was completed. Twenty-one people with chronic ABI were recruited in groups of two to three from community settings, allocated to either a TREATMENT (n = 11) or WAITLIST group (n = 10). Participants attended a 20-h group-based treatment over 6 weeks where they worked towards achieving a project that helped others. To determine feasibility, four criteria were used: demand, implementation, practicality and acceptability. A range of communication and QOL outcomes was used to determine a fifth feasibility criterion, initial efficacy. Some of these criteria were additionally used to evaluate the feasibility of the outcomes.
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: All participants received the treatment as allocated with high attendance and no dropouts. The treatment was feasible to deliver as intended and was highly acceptable to participants. Medium and large effect sizes were found from pre- to post-treatment, and from pre-treatment to follow-up for measures of conversation, perceived communicative ability and QOL.
CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS: Project-based treatment is feasible with indications of initial efficacy for both communication skills and QOL. The treatment provides a promising new approach for improving communication skills and QOL in people with chronic acquired brain injuries in the community setting.
在获得性脑损伤(ABI)后很长一段时间,交流障碍在人群中普遍存在且普遍存在。这些损伤对一个人受伤后的生活质量(QOL)有重大影响。基于项目的治疗是一种治疗方法,它可以在受伤后很长一段时间内对 ABI 患者的沟通技巧和 QOL 产生影响。这种治疗是在 ABI 患者选择的有意义的活动背景下进行的,在这种情况下,他们作为一个小组,共同努力实现有形的最终产品。
评估基于项目的治疗对改善 ABI 患者沟通技巧和生活质量的可行性和初步疗效。
完成了一项探索性对照试验,采用分组交替分配,6-8 周后随访。从社区环境中以两人或三人一组的方式招募了 21 名慢性 ABI 患者,将他们分配到治疗组(n=11)或候补组(n=10)。参与者参加了为期 6 周的 20 小时小组基础治疗,旨在实现帮助他人的项目。为了确定可行性,使用了四个标准:需求、实施、实用性和可接受性。使用了一系列沟通和 QOL 结果来确定第五个可行性标准,即初步疗效。其中一些标准还用于评估结果的可行性。
所有参与者都按照分配接受了治疗,并且出勤率高,没有退出。治疗按预期进行是可行的,并且受到参与者的高度认可。在会话、感知沟通能力和 QOL 方面,从治疗前到治疗后,以及从治疗前到随访都发现了中等和大的效应大小。基于项目的治疗在社区环境中为慢性获得性脑损伤患者提供了一种有希望的新方法,以改善沟通技巧和生活质量,具有可行性和初步疗效的迹象。