Department of Language and Communication Science, School of Health and Psychological Sciences City, University of London, London, UK.
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Wisconsin, Eau Claire, Wisconsin, USA.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2024 Mar-Apr;59(2):572-590. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12834. Epub 2022 Dec 30.
Rehabilitation for cognitive-communication impairments following brain injury can be complex given the heterogenous nature of impairments post injury. Project-based intervention has the potential to improve communication skills and create a meaningful real-life context where individuals collaborate to develop a concrete product, which benefits others. While evidence for this intervention is emerging, the COVID-19 pandemic prompted increased use of telehealth interventions to serve people with brain injury. This paper aims to describe a framework for the delivery of project-based intervention via telehealth within community rehabilitation settings; and present several case studies of telehealth groups completed in the United Kingdom and the United States during the COVID-19 pandemic.
A working group was formed to map the components of project-based intervention onto the rehabilitation treatment specification system (RTSS). This system is a conceptual framework that helps to explain the link between treatment theory and ingredients, allowing a clinician to clearly understand how and why a treatment works. First, a literature search was completed to identify eligible studies on project-based intervention after brain injury. Second, those studies were thematically mapped onto the RTSS to identify important intervention components. Third, the presence of these components was assessed for community brain injury groups delivered via telehealth in the United Kingdom and United States. These groups were further described using a taxonomy of social activities that help to describe the degree of meaningful social engagement.
The literature was described with a thematic RTSS summary. Treatment aims focus on skills training and self-efficacy, advocacy and self-empowerment, emotional well-being and quality of life, and collaboration and community belonging. Treatment ingredients involve a range of cognitive and behavioural supports to deliver meaningful activities and contexts to complete a project. Mechanisms of action involve learning by doing and cognitive and affective information processing. All four telehealth groups conducted in the United Kingdom and United States involved at least three treatment aims, >7 targets, and >8 treatment ingredients. All groups reported positive experiences from activities that involve working collaboratively to help others and contribute to society.
Project-based intervention delivered via telehealth has the potential for supporting people with acquired brain injury to improve their communication skills and engage in meaningful, collaborative activity. Application of the RTSS helps clinicians to understand the aims and therapeutic ingredients (or clinician activities) through which a person with brain injury may achieve specific treatment targets during the rehabilitation process.
What is already known on the subject Project-based interventions have the potential to improve cognitive, self-regulatory, behavioural and social communication skills, renegotiate identity and reaffirm sense of self, providing a positive impact on quality of life for persons with acquired brain injuries. Projects serve as a context for meaningful engagement for individuals in the chronic phase of traumatic brain injury recovery, without fulfilling work, family or social responsibilities. However, most published research has involved in-person projects and few projects have been delivered via telehealth. What this paper adds to existing knowledge While past published works have shared core principles of intervention, a variety of projects, durations, dosages and methods have been employed. The current paper provides a framework to support more consistent implementation. By mapping previous project-based interventions to the RTSS, clinicians will have a better understanding of the aims, targets, ingredients and theoretical underpinnings of project-based interventions. In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, the shift to telehealth moved interventions to a virtual context. The four case projects in this paper demonstrate that it is possible to conduct project-based interventions via telehealth and provides a clear description to guide clinicians in their delivery. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? This work begins to build the foundation for more rigorous, empirical examination of project-based interventions. By mapping project-based interventions to the RTSS, core aims, targets and ingredients are established that can be objectively examined. This investigation also provides a road map for clinicians who wish to implement this complex intervention.
由于脑损伤后损伤的异质性,脑损伤后的认知-沟通障碍的康复可能很复杂。基于项目的干预有可能提高沟通技能,并创造一个有意义的现实生活环境,让个人合作开发具体产品,造福他人。虽然这种干预措施的证据正在出现,但 COVID-19 大流行促使更多地使用远程医疗干预措施为脑损伤患者提供服务。本文旨在描述一种在社区康复环境中通过远程医疗提供基于项目的干预的框架;并介绍在 COVID-19 大流行期间,英国和美国完成的几个远程医疗小组的案例研究。
成立了一个工作组,将基于项目的干预措施的组成部分映射到康复治疗规范系统(RTSS)上。该系统是一个概念框架,有助于解释治疗理论和成分之间的联系,使临床医生能够清楚地理解治疗是如何以及为什么起作用的。首先,完成了一项文献搜索,以确定脑损伤后基于项目的干预措施的合格研究。其次,将这些研究主题映射到 RTSS 上,以确定重要的干预措施组成部分。第三,评估了英国和美国通过远程医疗提供的社区脑损伤小组的这些组成部分。这些小组进一步使用帮助描述有意义的社会参与程度的社交活动分类法进行描述。
对文献进行了主题 RTSS 总结。治疗目标侧重于技能培训和自我效能、倡导和自我赋权、情绪健康和生活质量以及合作和社区归属感。治疗成分涉及一系列认知和行为支持,以提供有意义的活动和环境来完成项目。作用机制涉及通过实践学习和认知和情感信息处理。在英国和美国进行的所有四个远程医疗小组都至少涉及三个治疗目标、>7 个目标和>8 个治疗成分。所有小组都报告了积极的活动体验,这些活动涉及合作帮助他人并为社会做出贡献。
通过远程医疗提供的基于项目的干预有可能支持后天脑损伤患者提高沟通技能并参与有意义的合作活动。RTSS 的应用有助于临床医生通过脑损伤患者在康复过程中可能实现特定治疗目标的治疗目标和治疗成分(或临床医生活动)来理解。
关于这个主题已经知道了什么
基于项目的干预有可能改善认知、自我监管、行为和社会沟通技能,重新协商身份和重新确认自我,为后天脑损伤患者的生活质量带来积极影响。项目为慢性创伤性脑损伤恢复期的个人提供了有意义的参与环境,而无需履行工作、家庭或社会责任。然而,大多数已发表的研究都涉及面对面的项目,很少有项目通过远程医疗进行。
本文对现有知识有何新增内容
虽然过去发表的作品分享了干预的核心原则,但已经采用了各种项目、持续时间、剂量和方法。目前的论文提供了一个支持更一致实施的框架。通过将以前的基于项目的干预措施映射到 RTSS,临床医生将更好地理解基于项目的干预措施的目标、目标、成分和理论基础。在 COVID-19 大流行之后,向远程医疗的转变将干预措施转移到了虚拟环境中。本文中的四个案例项目表明,通过远程医疗进行基于项目的干预是可行的,并提供了清晰的描述,以指导临床医生的实施。
这项工作有哪些潜在或实际的临床意义?
这项工作开始为基于项目的干预措施的更严格、实证研究奠定基础。通过将基于项目的干预措施映射到 RTSS,可以建立核心目标、目标和成分,以便进行客观检查。这项调查还为希望实施这种复杂干预措施的临床医生提供了路线图。