a Core Educator Faculty, Department of Medicine , Massachusetts General Hospital , Boston , MA , USA.
b Harvard Medical School , Boston , MA , USA.
Med Educ Online. 2019 Dec;24(1):1565044. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2018.1565044.
Informative writing is a valuable tool for learning and fostering the scientific process. Pearls4Peers (P4P) is an educational open-access website dedicated to scholarly blog posts in hospital medicine based on questions raised during ward teaching rounds. A goal of P4P is to enhance the learning experience of medical students and housestaff (i.e., interns and upper-level residents) by inviting them to write blog posts for a worldwide audience.
To describe our experience with inviting medical students and housestaff to contribute blog posts to a clinically oriented educational website with the aim of promoting concise evidence-based informative medical writing.
Medical students and housestaff assigned to the hospital ward team of an attending physician (FM) on the medical service were routinely invited to submit one or more posts or 'pearls' based on clinical questions raised during patient rounds. Selected features of submissions during the first 2 years of P4P (27 June 2015 through 26 June 2017) were then retrospectively reviewed and analyzed.
Of 156 pearls posted during the study period, 25 (16%) were contributed by medical students and 16 (10.3%) by housestaff. Medical students were significantly more likely to contribute than housestaff (19[70.4%] vs. 11 (9.6%], p < 0.01). Superfluous information was noted in 12 (29.3%) submissions. Word count exceeded the suggested limit of 200 words in 12 (29.3%) cases. An inverted pyramid structure, a widely recognized web writing format with the most important information presented at the outset, was noted in only 17 (41.5%) of entries. Unsolicited comments by contributors suggested a positive learning experience in writing the posts.
Writing clinically oriented concise blog posts appears feasible and may be an effective tool in enhancing the ward-based learning experience of medical students and housestaff. More formal instructions on the proper content and structure of blog posts seem warranted.
信息写作是学习和培养科学过程的一种有价值的工具。Pearls4Peers(P4P)是一个教育性的开放获取网站,致力于基于病房教学查房期间提出的问题撰写医院医学方面的学术博客文章。P4P 的目标是通过邀请医学生和住院医师(即实习医生和高年级住院医师)为全球读者撰写博客文章,来增强他们的学习体验。
描述我们邀请医学生和住院医师为一个以临床为导向的教育网站撰写博客文章的经验,旨在促进简洁的基于证据的信息性医学写作。
常规邀请在主治医生(FM)的医院病房团队工作的医学生和住院医师根据患者查房期间提出的临床问题提交一篇或多篇文章或“珍珠”。然后回顾性分析 P4P 前 2 年(2015 年 6 月 27 日至 2017 年 6 月 26 日)期间提交的内容的部分特征。
在研究期间发布的 156 个“珍珠”中,有 25 个(16%)由医学生贡献,16 个(10.3%)由住院医师贡献。医学生明显比住院医师更有可能做出贡献(19[70.4%]与 11(9.6%],p<0.01)。在 12 项(29.3%)提交的内容中注意到有多余的信息。在 12 项(29.3%)案例中,字数超过建议的 200 字限制。只有 17 项(41.5%)条目采用了倒金字塔结构,这是一种广泛认可的网络写作格式,将最重要的信息放在最前面。撰稿人未经请求的评论表明他们在撰写文章时获得了积极的学习体验。
撰写以临床为导向的简洁博客文章似乎是可行的,并且可能是增强医学生和住院医师基于病房学习体验的有效工具。似乎需要更正式的关于博客文章正确内容和结构的说明。