Xiao Y P, Tao X, Zhao C Y, Qu Y Q, Xie F, Ning Y
Department of Pathology, Obstetrics and Gynecology Hospital, Fudan University, Shanghai 200011, China.
Cervical Disease Center, Obstetrics and Gynecology Hospital, Fudan University, Shanghai 200011, China.
Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2019 Jan 25;54(1):19-23. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0529-567x.2019.01.005.
To investigate the relationship between various loop electrosurgical excision procedure (LEEP) margin status and residual high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) or worse at hysterectomy following conization. The relevant clinicopathological data were collected in the Obstetrics and Gynecology Hospital, Fudan University from Jan. 2014 to Dec. 2015, including 947 cases who underwent hysterectomy within 6 months of LEEP. The residual HSIL or worse at hysterectomy were analyzed among the groups. (1) Clear margins, involved margins, and without 1 mm negative margins. (2) Only one positive margin, two positive margins and three positive margins. (3) A positive margin of internal ostium of cervix, of external ostium of cervix and of the basement. (1) The histological evaluation of the uterine specimens showed residual HSIL or worse in 234 cases (24.7%, 234/947). The proportion of residual lesions was 7.3% (21/286) in population with clear margins, 33.2% (211/635) with involved margins, 7.7% (2/26) without 1 mm negative margins, respectively. The positive margins group had significant difference at the aspect of residual rate in contrast to the negative margins group and the without 1 mm negative margins group (0.01). Further studies conclusively showed that the proportion of residual lesions was very similar between the negative margins group and the without 1 mm negative margins group (0.05). (2) The involved margins were interpretable in 621 cases. This was detected in 25.3% (111/438) patients with only one positive margin, 47.4% (74/156) with two positive margins and 77.8% (21/27) among three positive margins, respectively (0.01). (3) Furthermore, there were 418 cases only one positive margin was definite, and the proportion of residual lesions was 31.0% (62/200) in population with a positive margin of internal ostium of cervix, 18.2% (31/170) of external ostium of cervix and 33.3% (16/48) of the basement. The residual rates were higher in the endocervical and basal margin groups than that in the ectocervical margin group, and the differences were significant (0.05). The risk of residual HSIL or worse is significantly greater with involved margins at hysterectomy following LEEP. Both the positive endocervical and basal margin are excellent predictors of residual diseases, while the without 1 mm negative margin may be not. Clinicians should avoid treating it as positive margin and prevent overtreatment.
探讨宫颈环形电切术(LEEP)切缘状态与锥切术后子宫切除时残留高级别鳞状上皮内病变(HSIL)或更严重病变之间的关系。收集2014年1月至2015年12月在复旦大学附属妇产科医院的相关临床病理资料,包括947例在LEEP术后6个月内行子宫切除术的患者。分析各组子宫切除时残留HSIL或更严重病变的情况。(1)切缘阴性、切缘累及、无1mm阴性切缘。(2)仅1个阳性切缘、2个阳性切缘和3个阳性切缘。(3)宫颈内口阳性切缘、宫颈外口阳性切缘和基底阳性切缘。(1)子宫标本的组织学评估显示,234例(24.7%,234/947)存在残留HSIL或更严重病变。切缘阴性组残留病变比例为7.3%(21/286),切缘累及组为33.2%(211/635),无1mm阴性切缘组为7.7%(2/26)。阳性切缘组与阴性切缘组及无1mm阴性切缘组相比,残留率方面有显著差异(P=0.01)。进一步研究明确显示,阴性切缘组与无1mm阴性切缘组之间残留病变比例非常相似(P=0.05)。(2)621例切缘累及情况可评估。仅1个阳性切缘的患者中,25.3%(111/438)检测到切缘累及;2个阳性切缘的患者中,47.4%(74/156)检测到切缘累及;3个阳性切缘的患者中,77.8%(21/27)检测到切缘累及,差异有统计学意义(P=0.01)。(3)此外有418例仅1个阳性切缘明确,宫颈内口阳性切缘组残留病变比例为31.0%(62/200),宫颈外口阳性切缘组为18.2%(31/170),基底阳性切缘组为33.3%(16/48)。宫颈管和基底切缘组的残留率高于宫颈外口切缘组,差异有统计学意义(P=0.05)。LEEP术后子宫切除时切缘累及,残留HSIL或更严重病变的风险显著更高。宫颈管阳性切缘和基底阳性切缘都是残留疾病的良好预测指标,而无1mm阴性切缘可能并非如此。临床医生应避免将其视为阳性切缘并防止过度治疗。