Braswell Lewis R, Reisig Dominic D, Sorenson Clyde E, Collins Guy D
Department of Entomology and Plant Pathology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC.
Department of Entomology and Plant Pathology, North Carolina State University, Vernon G. James Research and Extension Center, Plymouth, NC.
Environ Entomol. 2019 Apr 3;48(2):465-477. doi: 10.1093/ee/nvz006.
Bollworm (Helicoverpa zea Boddie) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) can cause economic losses in both non-Bt and Bt cotton. Larvae modify their behavior in the presence of Bt by moving away from terminals faster in Bt cotton compared to non-Bt cotton and avoiding Bt-treated diets. Our objectives were to understand differences in bollworm egg and larvae populations within, and dispersal away from, non-Bt and Bt pyramided-toxin cotton. We conducted small plot experiments in 2016 and 2017 to monitor on-plant egg and larval numbers, and off-plant dispersal of larvae, from non-Bt and different Bt toxin pyramided cotton. Bollworm adults preferred to oviposit in most Bt toxin pyramids compared to non-Bt; this was likely unrelated to detection of Bt by adults, but rather density-dependent aversion from high larval populations. First instar numbers were similar in all non-Bt/Bt toxin pyramids and dispersed at a similar rate. Second through fifth instar numbers were higher in non-Bt than Bt toxin pyramids but dispersed equally from all non-Bt/Bt toxin pyramids, regardless of Bt pyramid type. Development times of larvae were often slower in Bt toxin pyramids compared to non-Bt. Fifth instars were found in, and dispersing from, Bt toxin pyramids containing Vip3A, raising concerns of resistance development. Furthermore, differences in oviposition rate among non-Bt/Bt toxin pyramids and slowed development rate of larvae on Bt varieties could create inconsistencies in generation times emerging from Bt and non-Bt hosts, which could contribute to resistance development.
棉铃虫(Helicoverpa zea Boddie)(鳞翅目:夜蛾科)会在非转基因抗虫棉和转基因抗虫棉上造成经济损失。与非转基因抗虫棉相比,棉铃虫幼虫在转基因抗虫棉存在时会改变行为,更快地从棉株顶端离开,并避开经转基因抗虫棉处理的食物。我们的目标是了解非转基因抗虫棉和转多价毒素基因抗虫棉内棉铃虫卵和幼虫数量的差异以及幼虫从这些棉株上的扩散情况。我们在2016年和2017年进行了小区试验,以监测非转基因抗虫棉和不同转多价毒素基因抗虫棉上的棉株上的卵和幼虫数量以及幼虫向棉株外的扩散情况。与非转基因抗虫棉相比,棉铃虫成虫更喜欢在大多数转多价毒素基因抗虫棉上产卵;这可能与成虫对转基因抗虫棉的检测无关,而是与高幼虫种群密度依赖性厌恶有关。所有非转基因抗虫棉/转多价毒素基因抗虫棉上第一龄幼虫数量相似,扩散速度也相似。非转基因抗虫棉上第二至五龄幼虫数量高于转多价毒素基因抗虫棉,但从所有非转基因抗虫棉/转多价毒素基因抗虫棉上的扩散情况相同,与转多价毒素基因抗虫棉类型无关。与非转基因抗虫棉相比,转多价毒素基因抗虫棉上幼虫的发育时间通常较慢。在含有Vip3A的转多价毒素基因抗虫棉上发现了第五龄幼虫并观察到其扩散,这引发了对产生抗性的担忧。此外,非转基因抗虫棉/转多价毒素基因抗虫棉之间产卵率的差异以及转多价毒素基因抗虫棉品种上幼虫发育速度的减缓可能会导致来自转基因抗虫棉和非转基因抗虫棉宿主的世代时间不一致,这可能会导致抗性的产生。