Kitanosono Hiroko, Motomura Masakatsu, Tomita Hiroki, Iwanaga Hiroshi, Iwanaga Naoki, Irioka Takashi, Shiraishi Hirokazu, Tsujino Akira
Department of Neurology and Strokology, Nagasaki University Hospital.
Brain Nerve. 2019 Feb;71(2):167-174. doi: 10.11477/mf.1416201237.
A 63-year-old female who developed dizziness, diplopia and subsequent gait disturbance from September X-1 year was analyzed. The first neurological findings in May X year revealed cerebellar ataxia, weakness in the proximal limbs, decreased tendon reflexes, and autonomic symptoms (ADL:mRS 3). Furthermore, an incremental phenomenon was observed in the repetitive nerve stimulation test, and she was diagnosed with Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome (LEMS) based on the serum P/Q-type calcium channel (VGCC) antibody positivity. In addition, small cell lung cancer was detected by chest CT and bronchoscopy, and her cerebellar ataxia was diagnosed as paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration (PCD). Therefore, the patient underwent chemotherapy and radiotherapy from June in X year. Six months after initiation of treatment, her cerebellar ataxia had almost disappeared and she could walk without assistance (ADL:mRS 1). The P/Q-type VGCC antibodies were also negative at that time. Cases wherein cerebellar ataxia resolved almost completely in parallel with disappearance of the serum P/Q-type VGCC antibodies are of great interest. We conducted a systematic literature review of PCD-LEMS cases in Japan reported since P/Q-type calcium channel antibody measurement was reported in 1995. As a result, 13 cases (including our study) that concurrently displayed cerebellar ataxia and LEMS were selected. The average age of the 13 patients (10 males and 3 females) was 61.5 years. Small cell carcinoma was complicated in 11 patients (10 in the lung and 1 in the oropharynx); in the other 2 patients, cancer was not found at the time of reporting (the observation period was as short as 1-2 months). The time from onset to treatment ranged between 1 week and 10 months. While 1 of the 13 patients developed cerebellar ataxia during the subsequent course of the treatment, the remaining 12 had already developed cerebellar ataxia and LEMS symptoms, although their main neurologic finding was cerebellar ataxia and they were subsequently diagnosed with LEMS after electrophysiological testing and autoantibody detection. Small cell carcinoma was found in 11 patients. We define the pathology following such a certain clinical course as PCD-LEMS. The P/Q-type VGCC antibodies were positive in 11 of the 13 cases, although their antibody titers were not necessarily very high. Treatment for the associated small cell carcinoma might have improved the neurological findings in 9 of the 11 PCD-LEMS patients. The P/Q-type VGCC antibodies were measured before and after the treatment. The PCD-LEMS symptoms improved in all patients and their antibody titers decreased. These findings indicate that P/Q-type VGCC antibodies are involved in the pathology of PCD-LEMS. Appropriate and timely treatment, at least in PCD-LEMS patients in Japan, that actively treats any associated cancer can be expected to improve not only life prognosis but also cerebellar ataxia. (Received October 15, 2018; Accepted November 5, 2018; Published January 1, 2019).
对一名63岁女性进行了分析,该女性自X - 1年9月起出现头晕、复视及随后的步态障碍。X年5月的首次神经系统检查发现小脑共济失调、近端肢体无力、腱反射减弱及自主神经症状(日常生活能力量表:改良Rankin量表评分为3分)。此外,重复神经电刺激试验中观察到递增现象,基于血清P/Q型钙通道(电压门控钙通道)抗体阳性,她被诊断为兰伯特 - 伊顿肌无力综合征(LEMS)。另外,胸部CT和支气管镜检查发现了小细胞肺癌,其小脑共济失调被诊断为副肿瘤性小脑变性(PCD)。因此,该患者于X年6月接受了化疗和放疗。治疗开始6个月后,她的小脑共济失调几乎消失,能够独立行走(日常生活能力量表:改良Rankin量表评分为1分)。此时P/Q型电压门控钙通道抗体也呈阴性。小脑共济失调几乎与血清P/Q型电压门控钙通道抗体消失同时完全缓解的病例很值得关注。我们对自1995年报道P/Q型钙通道抗体检测以来日本报道的PCD - LEMS病例进行了系统的文献回顾。结果,选取了13例(包括我们的研究)同时出现小脑共济失调和LEMS的病例。13例患者(10例男性,3例女性)的平均年龄为61.5岁。11例患者合并小细胞癌(10例肺部,1例口咽);另外2例患者在报告时未发现癌症(观察期仅1 - 2个月)。从发病到治疗的时间为1周 - 10个月。13例患者中有1例在后续治疗过程中出现小脑共济失调,其余12例在出现症状时主要表现为小脑共济失调,尽管如此,经电生理检查和自身抗体检测后随后被诊断为LEMS。11例患者发现了小细胞癌。我们将遵循这种特定临床病程的病理情况定义为PCD - LEMS。13例病例中有11例P/Q型电压门控钙通道抗体呈阳性,尽管其抗体滴度不一定很高。11例PCD - LEMS患者中有9例针对相关小细胞癌的治疗可能改善了神经系统表现。在治疗前后检测了P/Q型电压门控钙通道抗体。所有患者的PCD - LEMS症状均改善且抗体滴度下降。这些发现表明P/Q型电压门控钙通道抗体参与了PCD - LEMS的病理过程。至少在日本的PCD - LEMS患者中,及时且适当的治疗,即积极治疗任何相关癌症,有望不仅改善生存预后,还能改善小脑共济失调。(2018年10月15日收到;2018年11月5日接受;2019年1月1日发表)