Bahonar Elahe, Najafi Ghezeljeh Tahereh, Haghani Hamid
Department of Critical Care Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Rashid Yasemi St., Valiasr St., 1996713883 Tehran, Iran.
Nursing Care Research Center, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
J Complement Integr Med. 2019 Feb 6;16(3):/j/jcim.2019.16.issue-3/jcim-2018-0106/jcim-2018-0106.xml. doi: 10.1515/jcim-2018-0106.
Background Traumatic comatose patients may experience disturbances in hemodynamic indices due to the nature of their disorder. This study aimed to compare the effects of nature sounds and reflexology on hemodynamic indices in traumatic comatose patients. Methods This randomized clinical trial using a factorial design was conducted on 120 traumatic comatose patients in two teaching hospitals in two urban areas of Iran. The patients were selected using a sequential sampling method and assigned into randomized quadruple blocks as control, nature sounds, reflexology and nature sounds-reflexology (combined) groups. The interventions were performed twice daily in two consecutive days lasting 30 min each time. The hemodynamic indices were measured before, and immediately, 30 min, and 2 h after the intervention using calibrated monitors. Descriptive and inferential statistics, including one-way ANOVA, Scheffe ad hoc, repeated measure ANOVA, Bonferroni ad hoc Chi-square test and Fisher's exact tests were used for data analysis via the SPSS software V.16. Results Significant differences were reported in terms of the mean arterial pressure between the control and reflexology groups (p=0.002), and the combined group (p=0.008) immediately after the interventions. The combined group showed statistically differences in systolic blood pressure compared to the nature sounds (p=0.007) and control (p=0.015) groups 30 min after the interventions. The nature sounds group showed differences in the pulse rate from the reflexology (p=0.048) and control (p=0.015) groups 30 min after the interventions in the second day. Conclusions While the immediate effects of the interventions on induction of the feeling of relaxation and tranquility, and reduction of hemodynamic indices were reported, they diminished over time. Nature sounds and reflexology as low-cost and relaxing tranquilizing methods can be used for the reduction of tension and improvement of hemodynamic indices among traumatic comatose patients.
背景 创伤性昏迷患者因其病情性质可能会出现血流动力学指标紊乱。本研究旨在比较自然声音和反射疗法对创伤性昏迷患者血流动力学指标的影响。方法 本随机临床试验采用析因设计,在伊朗两个城市地区的两家教学医院对120例创伤性昏迷患者进行研究。患者采用序贯抽样法选取,并随机分为四组,即对照组、自然声音组、反射疗法组和自然声音 - 反射疗法(联合)组。干预措施连续两天每天进行两次,每次持续30分钟。使用校准监测仪在干预前、干预后即刻、30分钟和2小时测量血流动力学指标。通过SPSS软件V.16使用描述性和推断性统计方法,包括单因素方差分析、谢费事后检验、重复测量方差分析、邦费罗尼事后检验、卡方检验和费舍尔精确检验进行数据分析。结果 干预后即刻,对照组与反射疗法组(p = 0.002)以及联合组(p = 0.008)之间的平均动脉压存在显著差异。干预后30分钟,联合组与自然声音组(p = 0.007)和对照组(p = 0.015)相比,收缩压有统计学差异。第二天干预后30分钟,自然声音组与反射疗法组(p = 0.048)和对照组(p = 0.015)相比,脉搏率存在差异。结论 虽然报告了干预措施对诱导放松和平静感以及降低血流动力学指标有即时效果,但随着时间推移这些效果会减弱。自然声音和反射疗法作为低成本且能放松镇静的方法,可用于减轻创伤性昏迷患者的紧张情绪并改善血流动力学指标。