Deng Bin, Fenn Norman E, Plake Kimberly S
California Northstate University College of Pharmacy, 9700 West Taron Drive, Elk Grove, CA 95757, United States.
The University of Texas at Tyler, Department of Clinical Sciences, 3900 University Blvd, Tyler, TX 75799, United States.
Curr Pharm Teach Learn. 2019 Feb;11(2):145-154. doi: 10.1016/j.cptl.2018.11.009. Epub 2018 Nov 22.
To describe the relationship between the use of a teaching objective structured clinical examination (TOSCE) and student confidence in a pharmacy skills laboratory.
To develop students' abilities in providing recommendations and patient education on selected drug products, third-year pharmacy students participated in a TOSCE in a men's and women's health laboratory. A 19-item, 5-point Likert scale survey was administered longitudinally to assess student confidence (1 = not all confident to 5 = extremely confident). An additional seven items (1 = strongly disagree to 5 = strongly agree) were added to the original 19-item survey to measure changes in confidence and attitude before and after a problem-based assessment.
Seventy-two students completed all five surveys administered throughout the semester. Students' confidence improved in multiple areas within the clinical skills and interpersonal communication skills categories. Students also indicated their confidence in using primary literature, electronic drug references, and package inserts to answer medication-related questions improved after the TOSCE implementation. Students agreed that the feedback they received from the TOSCE was beneficial to their performance on a problem-based assessment.
A TOSCE is a formative assessment that has the potential to improve student confidence in core competency areas immediately after an activity. However, its benefit may be short-term when a time gap exists. Further study is needed to assess long-term sustainability in student confidence over multiple laboratory activities throughout a semester.
描述教学目标结构化临床考试(TOSCE)的使用与学生在药学技能实验室中的信心之间的关系。
为培养学生对选定药品提供建议和患者教育的能力,三年级药学专业学生在男性和女性健康实验室参加了TOSCE。纵向开展一项包含19个项目、采用5分李克特量表的调查,以评估学生的信心(1 = 完全没有信心至5 = 极其自信)。在最初的19项调查中额外增加了7个项目(1 = 强烈反对至5 = 强烈同意),以衡量基于问题的评估前后信心和态度的变化。
72名学生完成了整个学期进行的所有五项调查。学生在临床技能和人际沟通技能类别中的多个领域的信心有所提高。学生还表示,在实施TOSCE后,他们在使用原始文献、电子药物参考文献和包装说明书回答与药物相关问题方面的信心有所提高。学生们一致认为,他们从TOSCE中获得的反馈对他们在基于问题的评估中的表现有益。
TOSCE是一种形成性评估,有可能在活动结束后立即提高学生在核心能力领域的信心。然而,当存在时间间隔时,其益处可能是短期的。需要进一步研究以评估学生在整个学期的多个实验室活动中的信心的长期可持续性。