Ferkin Michael H
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Memphis, Ellington Hall, Memphis, TN, 38152, USA.
Anim Cogn. 2019 May;22(3):445-452. doi: 10.1007/s10071-019-01250-9. Epub 2019 Feb 18.
For a scent mark to be informative it must provide a reliable, honest signal that allows individuals that detect it to predict fitness tradeoffs if they choose or not choose to respond to it. I argue that scent marks provide a great deal of information about the sender to receivers. The manner in which an animal uses this information to make decisions will depend on the context and manner in which it encounters these scent marks. Receivers can use the information found in the scent marks and odors to locate the donor, learn its identity, determine the donor's phenotype or genotype, and assess whether the scent marks were encountered earlier by conspecifics. For receivers to make potentially informed decisions, when they encounter the scent marks of conspecifics with whom they have had different experiences across a variety of contexts higher level cognitive processing involving procedural memory, episodic memory, autobiographical memory and making judgements of numerical discrimination would be required. Senders should have some insight into the receivers to increase the likelihood that the targets respond appropriately to the scent mark by reducing uncertainty. The sender's state or the current state of the environment and the context will affect when and where the scent marks were deposited. Decisions to deposit scent marks and respond to them must represent a tradeoff in the benefits and costs to the sender and receivers in terms of their fitness and survival. The actual tradeoff should be context dependent and reflect the experience, physiology, and life history constraints affecting the receiver. Calculating these tradeoffs likely involves some cognitive processing and requires some sort of information transfer between the sender and the receiver.
要使气味标记具有信息性,它必须提供一个可靠、真实的信号,使检测到它的个体在选择或不选择对其做出反应时,能够预测适应性权衡。我认为气味标记能向接收者提供大量关于发出者的信息。动物利用这些信息做出决策的方式将取决于它遇到这些气味标记的背景和方式。接收者可以利用在气味标记和气味中发现的信息来定位发出者、了解其身份、确定发出者的表型或基因型,并评估同种个体是否更早遇到过这些气味标记。为了让接收者做出可能明智的决策,当它们在各种背景下遇到与自己有不同经历的同种个体的气味标记时,就需要涉及程序记忆、情景记忆、自传体记忆以及进行数字辨别判断的高级认知处理。发出者应该对接收者有一定的了解,通过减少不确定性来增加目标对气味标记做出适当反应的可能性。发出者的状态或环境及背景的当前状态会影响气味标记的沉积时间和地点。决定留下气味标记并对其做出反应,必须在发出者和接收者的适应性和生存方面的收益和成本之间进行权衡。实际的权衡应该取决于具体情况,并反映影响接收者的经验、生理和生活史限制。计算这些权衡可能涉及一些认知处理,并且需要发出者和接收者之间进行某种信息传递。