Skowronek Rafał, Nowicka Joanna, Czech Ewa, Kulikowska Joanna
Katedra i Zakład Medycyny Sądowej i Toksykologii Sądowo-Lekarskiej, Wydział Lekarski w Katowicach, Śląski Uniwersytet Medyczny w Katowicach, Polska.
Zakład Histologii, Katedra Histologii i Embriologii, Wydział Lekarski w Katowicach, Śląski Uniwersytet Medyczny w Katowicach, Polska.
Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol. 2018;68(3):161-170. doi: 10.5114/amsik.2018.83093.
In medicolegal practice, rare cases associated with suicidal, criminal or accidental overdose of insulin are both analytically and forensically challenging. The determination of insulin in post-mortem blood has limited diagnostic value, mainly on account of post-mortem chemical degradation processes (particularly hemolysis), and hence is not useful in medicolegal practice.
The aims of the study were: 1) to assess the usefulness of the immunoradiometric method, used in clinical practice, for post-mortem measurement of insulin concentration in the intraocular fluid, 2) to preliminarily evaluate the usefulness of the obtained results for toxicological and medicolegal assessment, and 3) to verify on the basis of our own material the validity of the cited literature data on the effect of hemolysis on the result of insulin level determination in post-mortem blood.
The study material consisted of 93 samples of intraocular fluid collected during consecutive medicolegal autopsies performed in the Department of Forensic Medicine and Forensic Toxicology, Medical University of Silesia in Katowice. In addition, 10 samples of peripheral blood taken from living people (5 women and 5 men) for clinical and diagnostic purposes were analyzed. Insulin(e) IRMA KIT from IMMUNOTECH was used for the analyses.
In 86 (92.5%) samples, the insulin concentration was below the analytical sensitivity of the method (less than 0.5 μIU/ml), while in 7 cases it was in the range of 1.42-24.42 μIU/ml.
Determination of the insulin level in the intraocular fluid by the immunoradiometric method provides an opportunity for objective verification of poisoning, however this claim requires further research.
在法医学实践中,与自杀、犯罪或意外过量使用胰岛素相关的罕见案例在分析和法医鉴定方面都具有挑战性。死后血液中胰岛素的测定诊断价值有限,主要是由于死后化学降解过程(特别是溶血),因此在法医学实践中并无用处。
本研究的目的是:1)评估临床实践中使用的免疫放射分析法用于测定眼内液中胰岛素浓度的实用性,2)初步评估所得结果在毒理学和法医学评估中的实用性,3)根据我们自己的材料验证引用文献中关于溶血对死后血液中胰岛素水平测定结果影响的数据的有效性。
研究材料包括在卡托维兹西里西亚医科大学法医学与法医毒理学系连续进行的法医尸检过程中收集的93份眼内液样本。此外,还分析了10份从活人(5名女性和5名男性)身上采集的用于临床诊断目的的外周血样本。使用IMMUNOTECH公司的胰岛素免疫放射分析试剂盒进行分析。
在86份(92.5%)样本中,胰岛素浓度低于该方法的分析灵敏度(低于0.5 μIU/ml),而在7例样本中,其浓度范围为1.42 - 24.42 μIU/ml。
通过免疫放射分析法测定眼内液中的胰岛素水平为客观验证中毒情况提供了机会,然而这一说法需要进一步研究。