Elomaa Minna, Hotta Jaakko, de C Williams Amanda C, Forss Nina, Äyräpää Anni, Kalso Eija, Harno Hanno
Pain Clinic, Department of Anaesthesiology, Intensive Care and Pain Medicine, Helsinki University Hospital and University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Clinical Neurosciences, Neurology, Helsinki University Hospital and University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Scand J Pain. 2019 Apr 24;19(2):257-270. doi: 10.1515/sjpain-2018-0098.
Background and aims Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) often recovers spontaneously within the first year, but when it becomes chronic, available rehabilitative therapies (pharmacological management, physiotherapy, and psychological intervention) have limited effectiveness. This study examined the effect of a 12-week intensive outpatient rehabilitation on pain relief and function in chronic CRPS patients. Rehabilitation program included memantine and morphine treatment (added to patient's prior pain medication) and concurrent psychological and physiotherapeutic intervention. Primary outcome measure was a change in CRPS symptom count and secondary outcomes were motor performance, psychological factors, pain intensity, and quality of life. Methods Ten patients with chronic upper limb CRPS I (median 2.9 years, range 8 months to 12 years) were recruited to the study and were assessed before and after the intervention. Hand motor function of the patients was evaluated by an independent physiotherapist. There were standardized questionnaires for depression, pain anxiety, pain acceptance, quality of life, and CRPS symptom count. In addition, psychological factors were evaluated by a semi-structured interview. Severity of experienced pain was rated at movement and at rest. In addition, a video experiment of a hand action observation was conducted pre- and post-intervention to study possible change in neuronal maladaptation. Intervention consisted of pharmacological, psychological and physiotherapeutic treatment. First, 10 mg daily morphine was started and increased gradually to 30 mg daily, if tolerated. After 30 mg/day or tolerated dose of morphine was achieved, 5 mg daily memantine was started and increased gradually to 40 mg, if tolerated. Psychological intervention consisted of weekly group sessions, using cognitive and behavioral methods (relaxation, behavioral activation, and exposure) and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) and daily home practice. Physiotherapeutic intervention consisted of graded motor imagery and physiotherapy exercises with weekly group sessions and/or individual guidance by the physiotherapist, and individual exercise of the affected upper limb. Results Multimodal intensive intervention resulted in significant decrease in CRPS symptom count. The effect was strongest in motor and trophic symptoms (19% decrease after intervention) and in sensory symptoms (18% decrease). Additionally, improvement was seen in some, but not all, secondary outcomes (movement pain, motor symptoms, change in perceptions during video experiment of hand actions, and summary index with motor functioning, pain, and psychological factors). There were no dropouts. Conclusions Intensive 12-week multimodal intervention reduced some CRPS symptoms but was not sufficient to alter patients' rest pain, distress, or quality of life. Implications These results support the efficacy of an interdisciplinary rehabilitation program for pain and function in chronic CRPS patients. After intervention, some CRPS symptoms reduced and function improved, but distress and quality of life were unchanged. This may be due to the relatively short duration of this program; to delayed effects; to particular cognitive problems of CPRS patients; and/or to low distress levels at baseline that make statistically significant reduction less likely.
背景与目的 复杂性区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)通常在第一年内自发恢复,但当它变为慢性时,现有的康复治疗(药物治疗、物理治疗和心理干预)效果有限。本研究考察了为期12周的强化门诊康复对慢性CRPS患者疼痛缓解和功能的影响。康复计划包括美金刚和吗啡治疗(添加到患者先前的止痛药物中)以及同时进行的心理和物理治疗干预。主要结局指标是CRPS症状计数的变化,次要结局包括运动表现、心理因素、疼痛强度和生活质量。方法 招募了10例慢性上肢CRPS I患者(中位数2.9年,范围8个月至12年)参与本研究,并在干预前后进行评估。患者的手部运动功能由一名独立的物理治疗师进行评估。有关于抑郁、疼痛焦虑、疼痛接受度、生活质量和CRPS症状计数的标准化问卷。此外,通过半结构化访谈评估心理因素。在运动和休息时对所经历疼痛的严重程度进行评分。此外,在干预前后进行了手部动作观察的视频实验,以研究神经元适应不良的可能变化。干预包括药物、心理和物理治疗。首先,开始每日10毫克吗啡治疗,若耐受则逐渐增加至每日30毫克。在达到每日30毫克或吗啡的耐受剂量后,开始每日5毫克美金刚治疗,若耐受则逐渐增加至40毫克。心理干预包括每周一次的小组会议,采用认知和行为方法(放松、行为激活和暴露)以及接受与承诺疗法(ACT)和每日家庭练习。物理治疗干预包括分级运动想象和物理治疗练习,每周小组会议和/或由物理治疗师进行个体指导,以及受影响上肢的个体锻炼。结果 多模式强化干预导致CRPS症状计数显著减少。在运动和营养症状方面效果最强(干预后减少19%),在感觉症状方面(减少18%)。此外,在一些但并非所有次要结局方面有改善(运动疼痛、运动症状、手部动作视频实验期间感知的变化以及运动功能、疼痛和心理因素的综合指数)。没有患者退出。结论 为期12周的多模式强化干预减少了一些CRPS症状,但不足以改变患者的静息痛、痛苦或生活质量。意义 这些结果支持了跨学科康复计划对慢性CRPS患者疼痛和功能的疗效。干预后,一些CRPS症状减轻,功能改善,但痛苦和生活质量未改变。这可能是由于该计划持续时间相对较短;由于延迟效应;由于CRPS患者特殊的认知问题;和/或由于基线时痛苦水平较低,使得统计学上显著降低的可能性较小。