Griffiths Grace S, Thompson Bronwyn L, Snell Deborah L, Dunn Jennifer A
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and Musculoskeletal Medicine, University of Otago, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Hand Ther. 2023 Mar;28(1):16-32. doi: 10.1177/17589983221138610. Epub 2023 Feb 22.
Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) is most common in the upper limb and associated with high disability. The purpose of this review was to critically appraise and synthesise literature exploring non-pharmacological treatment for upper limb CRPS, to guide upper-limb-specific management.
Using an integrative review methodology, 13 databases were searched to identify all published studies on non-pharmacological management of upper limb CRPS. The Crowe Critical Appraisal Tool was used to provide quality ratings for included studies, and analysis employed a qualitative descriptive approach.
From 236 abstracts reviewed, 113 full texts were read, and 38 articles selected for data extraction. Designs included single case ( = 14), randomised controlled trial ( = 8), prospective cohort ( = 8), case series ( = 4), retrospective ( = 3), and mixed methods ( = 1). Interventions were categorised as sensory retraining ( = 13), kinesiotherapy ( = 7), manual therapies ( = 7), physical modalities ( = 6), and interdisciplinary treatment programmes ( = 5). All studies measured pain intensity, and most ( = 24) measured physical parameters such as strength, movement, or perceptual abilities. Few measured patient-rated function ( = 13) or psychological factors ( = 4). Quality ratings ranged from 30% to 93%, with a median of 60%.
Methodological quality of non-pharmacological treatment approaches for upper limb CRPS is overall poor. Movement, desensitisation, and graded functional activity remain the mainstays of intervention. However, despite the impact of CRPS on wellbeing and function, psychological factors and functional outcomes are infrequently addressed. Further robust research is required to determine which aspects of treatment have the greatest influence on which symptoms, and when and how these should be introduced and progressed.
复杂性区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)在上肢最为常见,且与高度残疾相关。本综述的目的是批判性地评估和综合探索上肢CRPS非药物治疗的文献,以指导上肢特异性管理。
采用综合综述方法,检索13个数据库,以识别所有已发表的关于上肢CRPS非药物管理的研究。使用克劳批判性评估工具为纳入研究提供质量评级,并采用定性描述方法进行分析。
在审查的236篇摘要中,阅读了113篇全文,选择了38篇文章进行数据提取。设计包括单病例(n = 14)、随机对照试验(n = 8)、前瞻性队列研究(n = 8)、病例系列(n = 4)、回顾性研究(n = 3)和混合方法研究(n = 1)。干预措施分为感觉再训练(n = 13)、运动疗法(n = 7)、手法治疗(n = 7)、物理治疗(n = 6)和跨学科治疗方案(n = 5)。所有研究均测量了疼痛强度,大多数(n = 24)测量了身体参数,如力量、运动或感知能力。很少有研究测量患者自评功能(n = 13)或心理因素(n = 4)。质量评级范围为30%至93%,中位数为60%。
上肢CRPS非药物治疗方法的方法学质量总体较差。运动、脱敏和分级功能活动仍然是主要的干预措施。然而,尽管CRPS对幸福感和功能有影响,但心理因素和功能结局很少得到关注。需要进一步进行有力的研究,以确定治疗的哪些方面对哪些症状有最大影响,以及何时以及如何引入和推进这些治疗。