Visentin Sindi, Massaro Luca, Viel Guido, Cecchetto Giovanni, Montisci Massimo
Legal Medicine and Toxicology, University-Hospital of Padova, 35121, Padova, Italy.
Via degli Artigiani 4, 35042 Este, Padova, Italy.
Forensic Sci Int. 2019 Apr;297:148-155. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2019.01.029. Epub 2019 Feb 2.
Death scene investigation (DSI) is critically important for the identification of the manner of death. The present study aims to present a scoring system for the correct framing of a case as a suicide starting from the DSI and its preliminary application. The method is based on five items: (1) statistical frequency of the method adopted; (2) victim's history of mental illness; (3) circumstantial data; (4) number of means; (5) compatibility of means and injuries with suicidal dynamics; and the application of a correction factor if suicide risk indicators are present. We blindly analyzed 180 cases of violent deaths equally divided into suicides, homicides and accidental deaths and the results obtained were compared with the established dynamics of death. The proposed method has proven to be efficient in the identification of suicide at the DSI, but further on-site studies making use of a wider number of cases is necessary.
死亡现场调查(DSI)对于确定死亡方式至关重要。本研究旨在提出一种评分系统,以便从死亡现场调查及其初步应用开始,正确地将案件定性为自杀。该方法基于五个项目:(1)所采用方法的统计频率;(2)受害者的精神疾病史;(3)间接证据;(4)手段数量;(5)手段与损伤与自杀动态的兼容性;如果存在自杀风险指标,则应用校正因子。我们对180例暴力死亡病例进行了盲法分析,这些病例平均分为自杀、他杀和意外死亡三类,并将所得结果与既定的死亡动态进行了比较。所提出的方法已被证明在死亡现场调查中识别自杀方面是有效的,但有必要进一步开展现场研究,纳入更多病例。