Reid Struan, Maskell Peter D, Maskell Dawn L
International Centre for Brewing and Distilling, School of Engineering and Physical Sciences, Heriot-Watt University, Riccarton, Edinburgh, UK.
School of Science, Engineering and Technology, Abertay University, Dundee, Scotland, UK.
Sci Justice. 2019 Mar;59(2):210-213. doi: 10.1016/j.scijus.2018.11.005. Epub 2018 Nov 19.
Forensic practitioners regularly use the Widmark equation to determine theoretical blood alcohol concentrations for use in cases involving alcohol. It is important with these calculations to determine the uncertainty associated with any result. Previous work has investigated the uncertainty in percent alcohol by volume (%ABV) from beers produced by small independent breweries in the UK but did not study the top selling beers in the UK. The top selling lagers and ales/bitters in the UK were identified by sales volume and the %ABV determined. These data was then used to determine the percent coefficient of variation (%CV) that should be used by forensic practitioners when constructing alcohol technical defence reports for use in forensic cases. These samples, from what may be described as 'big' brewers, were determined to have a smaller root mean square error (RMSE) (±0.1%v/v, n = 35), and %CV than those previously reported for beers produced by small, independent breweries in the UK. The results from this study shows that different RMSE's should be used for %ABV when determining the uncertainty of results from Widmark calculations depending if the drinks consumed have been from either 'big' brewers or small, independent breweries.
法医从业者经常使用维德马克方程来确定涉及酒精案件中使用的理论血液酒精浓度。在这些计算中,确定与任何结果相关的不确定性很重要。此前的研究调查了英国小型独立啤酒厂生产的啤酒中酒精体积百分比(%ABV)的不确定性,但没有研究英国最畅销的啤酒。通过销量确定了英国最畅销的淡啤酒和麦芽酒/苦啤酒,并测定了其%ABV。然后,这些数据被用于确定法医从业者在构建用于法医案件的酒精技术辩护报告时应使用的变异系数百分比(%CV)。这些来自可被描述为“大型”啤酒厂的样本,其均方根误差(RMSE)(±0.1%v/v,n = 35)和%CV比之前报道的英国小型独立啤酒厂生产的啤酒要小。这项研究的结果表明,在根据饮用的饮料是来自“大型”啤酒厂还是小型独立啤酒厂来确定维德马克计算结果的不确定性时,应使用不同的RMSE来计算%ABV。