Horiuchi Sayaka, Ozaki Akihiko, Inoue Mariko, Aida Jun, Yamaoka Kazue
Graduate School of Public Health, Teikyo University.
Department of Surgery, Jyoban Hospital of Tokiwa Foundation.
Tohoku J Exp Med. 2019 Feb;247(2):129-137. doi: 10.1620/tjem.247.129.
Media coverage of disasters potentially damages mental health. Moreover, its effects may differ as recipients may have different emotional responses toward media. The present study examined whether social capital, known to be protective against mental problems, influences a recipient's emotional response toward news media broadcasting of natural disasters via newspapers, television and internet in Japan. Three social capital components, social participation, social support and cognitive social capital, were considered in the present study as each component reportedly had different effect on mental health. This nationwide cross-sectional survey was undertaken in 2015 among 1,200 Japanese citizens aged 15 to 79 years who were selected using the multi-stage sampling procedure. Data were collected via the drop-off pick-up method using a printed structured questionnaire. Negative and positive emotions were classified based on recipients' responses against news media. Among 1,190 participants who reported emotions toward news media, 30.9% (368) had experienced any natural disasters, 37.4% (445) belonged to at least one formal or informal organization (social participation), 40.2% (478) had high social support, and 68.8% (819) had high cognitive social capital. High social support was associated with both reduced negative emotional response (OR 0.66, 95% Confidence Interval (CI) 0.47-0.93) and increased positive emotional response (OR 1.48, 95% CI 1.04-2.12) in multivariate analyses, while high cognitive social capital was only associated with increased positive emotional response (OR 1.62, 95% CI 1.11-2.37). These results suggest protective effects of social support and cognitive social capital against news media coverage of natural disasters.
媒体对灾难的报道可能会损害心理健康。此外,其影响可能因受众对媒体的情感反应不同而有所差异。本研究调查了已知对心理问题有保护作用的社会资本,是否会影响日本受众对通过报纸、电视和互联网播放的自然灾害新闻媒体的情感反应。本研究考虑了社会资本的三个组成部分,即社会参与、社会支持和认知社会资本,因为据报道每个组成部分对心理健康都有不同的影响。这项全国性的横断面调查于2015年对1200名年龄在15至79岁之间的日本公民进行,这些公民是使用多阶段抽样程序选取的。数据通过使用印刷结构化问卷的上门回收法收集。根据受众对新闻媒体的反应对负面和正面情绪进行分类。在1190名报告了对新闻媒体情感的参与者中,30.9%(368人)经历过任何自然灾害,37.4%(445人)属于至少一个正式或非正式组织(社会参与),40.2%(478人)有较高的社会支持,68.8%(819人)有较高的认知社会资本。在多变量分析中,高社会支持与负面情绪反应减少(比值比0.66,95%置信区间(CI)0.47 - 0.93)和正面情绪反应增加(比值比1.48,95% CI 1.04 - 2.12)均相关,而高认知社会资本仅与正面情绪反应增加相关(比值比1.62,95% CI 1.11 - 2.37)。这些结果表明社会支持和认知社会资本对新闻媒体报道自然灾害具有保护作用。