Maruta Akinori, Iwashita Takuji, Uemura Shinya, Yoshida Kensaku, Yasuda Ichiro, Shimizu Masahito
First Department of Internal Medicine, Gifu University Hospital, Japan.
Department of Gastroenterology, Teikyo University Mizonokuchi Hospital, Japan.
Intern Med. 2019 Jun 15;58(12):1673-1679. doi: 10.2169/internalmedicine.2047-18. Epub 2019 Feb 25.
Objective Endoscopic ultrasound (EUS) is a safe and accurate examination for evaluating the presence of common bile duct stones (CBDSs). The EUS-first approach, where EUS is performed before endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) for patients suspected of having CBDSs, may help reduce the risk of ERCP-related adverse events and save manpower by avoiding unnecessary ERCP. To evaluate the efficacy of the EUS-first approach in patients with suspected CBDSs. Methods Between April 2012 and March 2016, 104 patients who underwent the EUS-first approach for suspected CBDSs were retrospectively evaluated. The relevant outcomes were the short- and long-term adverse event rates and the ERCP avoidance rate. Results EUS findings were positive for CBDSs in 52 patients, showed sludge formation or possible CBDSs in 4 patients, and were negative for CBDSs in 42 patients (but positive for other diseases in 6). Sixty-two patients (62/104, 59.6%) underwent ERCP, and proper treatments were successfully performed in all but 1 who underwent only cholangiography. In the remaining 42 patients (42/104, 40.4%), ERCP was omitted based on the EUS findings. Early adverse events were recognized in 0% of the EUS-only group and 8 patients (12.9%) in the EUS+ERCP group (p=0.02). Regarding late adverse events, recurrent CBDSs occurred in 1 patient (2.3%) in the EUS-only group and 2 (3.2%) in the EUS+ERCP group (p=1.0). Conclusion The EUS-first approach in patients with suspected CBDSs was useful for reducing early adverse events associated with ERCP without increasing the late adverse event rate, as EUS enabled the avoidance of unnecessary ERCP.
目的 内镜超声(EUS)是评估胆总管结石(CBDS)存在情况的一种安全且准确的检查方法。对于疑似患有CBDS的患者,先进行EUS检查再进行内镜逆行胰胆管造影(ERCP)的EUS优先方法,可能有助于降低ERCP相关不良事件的风险,并通过避免不必要的ERCP节省人力。本研究旨在评估EUS优先方法对疑似CBDS患者的疗效。方法 回顾性评估2012年4月至2016年3月期间104例采用EUS优先方法诊断疑似CBDS的患者。相关结局指标为短期和长期不良事件发生率以及ERCP避免率。结果 52例患者EUS检查结果显示存在CBDS,4例显示有胆泥形成或可能存在CBDS,42例患者EUS检查结果显示无CBDS(但6例存在其他疾病)。62例患者(62/104,59.6%)接受了ERCP,除1例仅进行胆管造影的患者外,其余患者均成功进行了适当治疗。其余42例患者(42/104,40.4%)根据EUS检查结果未进行ERCP。仅行EUS检查的患者中早期不良事件发生率为0%,EUS+ERCP组有8例患者(12.9%)发生早期不良事件(p=0.02)。关于晚期不良事件,仅行EUS检查的患者中有1例(2.3%)复发CBDS,EUS+ERCP组有2例(3.2%)复发(p=1.0)。结论 对于疑似CBDS患者采用EUS优先方法有助于降低与ERCP相关的早期不良事件发生率,且不会增加晚期不良事件发生率因为EUS能够避免不必要的ERCP。