Yang Dongju, Du Qiaoyi, Huang Zhaoyang, Li Liping, Zhang Zhang, Zhang Liping, Zhao Xin, Zhao Xuan, Li Ting, Lin Yicong, Wang Yuping
Department of Neurology, Xuanwu Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
Beijing Key Laboratory of Neuromodulation, Beijing, China.
Front Neurol. 2019 Feb 5;10:50. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2019.00050. eCollection 2019.
Epileptic spasms (ES) is a severe seizure type and lack of adequate methods for controlling of clinical attacks. Previous studies have indicated that cathodal transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) reduces seizure frequency for patients with epilepsy. ES are proposed to have a focal cortical origin. We hypothesized that patients with ES exhibit hyperactive network hubs in the parietal lobe, and that cathodal tDCS targeting the bilateral parietal region can reduce seizure frequency in patients with pharmacoresistant ES. The present study consisted of three basic phases: (a) a pre-treatment monitoring period for 14 days; (b) a consecutive 14-day treatment period during which patients were treated with 1 or 2 mA cathode tDCS for 40 min once per day; (c) and a follow-up period for at least 28 days. During the first 20 min of treatment, the cathode was placed over the right parietal lobe (P4) with the reference electrode over the contralateral supra-orbital area. In the second 20 min, the cathode was placed over the left parietal lobe (P3), with the reference electrode over the contralateral supra-orbital area. All patients received active tDCS treatment, and some patients underwent more than one treatment block. Patients maintained a seizure diary throughout the study. Antiepileptic drug therapy remained unchanged throughout the study. K-related samples Friedman tests and two-related samples tests were used to analyze data from all patients. Seven patients with pharmacoresistant ES were included, receiving a total of eighteen 14-day blocks of tDCS treatment. We observed a significant difference in seizure frequency at the second month ( = 0.028, unadjusted), as well as a trend toward decreased seizure frequency at the fourth month ( = 0.068, unadjusted) of the first follow-up, relative to baseline. Three of seven patients (42.9%) exhibited sustained seizure reduction, while one (14.3%) experienced a short-term reduction in seizure frequency following cathodal tDCS treatment. Treatment was well tolerated in all patients. Repeated tDCS with the cathode placed over the bilateral parietal region is safe and may be effective for reducing seizure frequency in a subgroup of patients with pharmacoresistant ES.
癫痫性痉挛(ES)是一种严重的癫痫发作类型,目前缺乏控制临床发作的有效方法。先前的研究表明,阴极经颅直流电刺激(tDCS)可降低癫痫患者的发作频率。ES被认为起源于局灶性皮质。我们假设ES患者在顶叶表现出过度活跃的网络枢纽,并且针对双侧顶叶区域的阴极tDCS可以降低药物难治性ES患者的发作频率。本研究包括三个基本阶段:(a)为期14天的治疗前监测期;(b)为期14天的连续治疗期,在此期间患者每天接受1或2 mA的阴极tDCS治疗,每次40分钟;(c)至少为期28天的随访期。在治疗的前20分钟,阴极置于右侧顶叶(P4),参考电极置于对侧眶上区域。在接下来的20分钟内,阴极置于左侧顶叶(P3),参考电极置于对侧眶上区域。所有患者均接受了主动tDCS治疗,一些患者接受了不止一个治疗疗程。在整个研究过程中,患者都要记录癫痫发作日记。在整个研究过程中,抗癫痫药物治疗保持不变。采用K相关样本Friedman检验和两相关样本检验对所有患者的数据进行分析。纳入了7例药物难治性ES患者,共接受了18个为期14天的tDCS治疗疗程。我们观察到,在第一次随访的第二个月,癫痫发作频率有显著差异(P = 0.028,未校正),在第四个月也有癫痫发作频率下降的趋势(P = 0.068,未校正),相对于基线水平。7例患者中有3例(42.9%)癫痫发作持续减少,1例(14.3%)在阴极tDCS治疗后癫痫发作频率出现短期下降。所有患者对治疗耐受性良好。将阴极置于双侧顶叶区域进行重复tDCS是安全的,并且可能对降低一部分药物难治性ES患者的癫痫发作频率有效。