Nakagawa Ichiro, Park Hun Soo, Kotsugi Masashi, Wada Takeshi, Takeshima Yasuhiro, Matsuda Ryosuke, Nishimura Fumihiko, Yamada Syuichi, Motoyama Yasushi, Park Young Su, Kichikawa Kimihiko, Nakase Hiroyuki
Department of Neurosurgery, Nara Medical University, Nara, Japan.
Department of Neurosurgery, Nara Medical University, Nara, Japan.
World Neurosurg. 2019 Jun;126:e473-e479. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2019.02.074. Epub 2019 Feb 28.
Chronic subdural hematoma (CSDH) is generally treated by burr-hole irrigation, but it can recur despite repeating these procedures. Embolization of the middle meningeal artery (MMA) has recently been proposed as a curative treatment for CSDH, but evidence for the indication and timing of MMA embolization is not definitive. The present study retrospectively analyzed the effects and safety of MMA embolization among patients with persistent CSDH recurrence.
We retrospectively assessed data from 381 consecutive patients who underwent burr-hole irrigation for CSDH between 2009 and 2017. Recurrent symptomatic ipsilateral CSDH in 71 (18%) patients was treated by a second burr-hole irrigation, and 20 of them had a further symptomatic CSDH recurrence thereafter. Those with persistent ipsilateral CSDH recurrence were treated by MMA embolization. Before the MMA embolization procedures, the amount of hematoma membrane enhancement determined using superselective MMA angiography-DynaCT imaging was classified into 3 stages.
Embolization of the MMA proceeded without perioperative complications or further CSDH recurrence. The interval between recurrence and the amount of hematoma membrane enhancement significantly correlated (first to second and second to third treatments: P = 0.012 and P = 0.017, respectively). The frequency of bilateral CSDH was significantly higher and the recurrence interval between the first and second treatments was significantly shorter in the repeated recurrences group compared with the recurrence group (P = 0.023 and P = 0.006, respectively).
Repeatedly recurrent CSDH can be safely treated and cured by MMA embolization. Hematoma membrane enhancement pattern using DynaCT images can predict repeated recurrences CSDH.
慢性硬膜下血肿(CSDH)一般采用钻孔冲洗治疗,但即便重复这些操作仍可能复发。最近有人提出栓塞脑膜中动脉(MMA)作为CSDH的一种根治性治疗方法,但MMA栓塞的适应症和时机的证据并不确凿。本研究回顾性分析了MMA栓塞对持续性CSDH复发患者的疗效和安全性。
我们回顾性评估了2009年至2017年间连续381例行CSDH钻孔冲洗术患者的数据。71例(18%)患者出现同侧复发性有症状CSDH,接受了第二次钻孔冲洗,其中20例此后又出现有症状的CSDH复发。那些同侧CSDH持续复发的患者接受了MMA栓塞治疗。在进行MMA栓塞手术前,使用超选择性MMA血管造影-DynaCT成像确定的血肿膜强化程度分为3个阶段。
MMA栓塞过程中未出现围手术期并发症或CSDH进一步复发。复发与血肿膜强化程度之间的间隔有显著相关性(第一次至第二次和第二次至第三次治疗:P分别为0.012和0.017)。与复发组相比,反复复发组双侧CSDH的发生率显著更高,且第一次和第二次治疗之间的复发间隔显著更短(P分别为0.023和0.006)。
反复复发的CSDH可通过MMA栓塞安全有效地治疗。利用DynaCT图像的血肿膜强化模式可预测CSDH的反复复发。