Silberman H, Silberman A W
JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr. 1986 Mar-Apr;10(2):151-4. doi: 10.1177/0148607186010002151.
Lipid-based total parenteral nutrition (TPN) may have an advantage over glucose-based TPN in certain patients because less carbon dioxide is produced. This conclusion, however, does not properly derive from respiratory quotient (RQ) data. Stoichiometric analysis of glucose and lipid metabolism leads to conclusions similar clinically but at variance conceptually with those based on RQ. Thus, changing from glucose to lipid oxidation is associated with an 11% increase in oxygen consumption, a 23% decrease in carbon dioxide production, and a fall in RQ. In contrast, the diversion of glucose metabolism to synthesis of palmitylstearyloleyl triglyceride results in an 8-fold increase in RQ, but contrary to widely published concepts, the rate of carbon dioxide production falls by 68%. However, even this reduced carbon dioxide production associated with lipogenesis is undesirable because it is not associated with significant ATP production.
基于脂质的全胃肠外营养(TPN)在某些患者中可能比基于葡萄糖的TPN具有优势,因为产生的二氧化碳较少。然而,这一结论并非恰当地源于呼吸商(RQ)数据。葡萄糖和脂质代谢的化学计量分析得出的临床结论相似,但在概念上与基于RQ的结论不同。因此,从葡萄糖氧化转变为脂质氧化与氧气消耗增加11%、二氧化碳产生减少23%以及RQ下降有关。相比之下,将葡萄糖代谢转向合成棕榈酰硬脂酰油酰甘油三酯会导致RQ增加8倍,但与广泛发表的概念相反,二氧化碳产生速率下降了68%。然而,即使这种与脂肪生成相关的二氧化碳产生减少也是不可取的,因为它与显著的ATP产生无关。