Kwong Ava, Cheng Ka-Leung Danny, Hsue Chan-Chee Victor, Hui Sze-Ki, Leung Ching-Yu Roland, Leung Kwong-Chuen Angus, Ngan Kai-Cheong Roger, Soong Sung Inda
Department of Surgery, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
Department of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
Asia Pac J Clin Oncol. 2019 Mar;15 Suppl 2:20-31. doi: 10.1111/ajco.13116. Epub 2019 Mar 6.
BRCA mutation (BRCAmut) testing is an important tool for the risk assessment, prevention and early diagnosis of breast cancer (BC) and ovarian cancer (OC), and more recently, for determining patient susceptibility to targeted therapy. This study assessed the current BRCAmut testing patterns and explored physicians' perspectives on the utilities and optimal sequencing of the testing, in order to facilitate and standardize testing practices.
Medical specialists in BC and OC in Hong Kong were invited to complete a questionnaire on BRCAmut testing practices. A panel of specialists with extensive BRCAmut testing experience was also convened to develop consensus statements on testing, using the Delphi method and an anonymous electronic voting system.
The survey respondents (n = 71) recognized family history (FH) of BC and/or OC and an early age of onset as key factors for referring BRCAmut testing. The proportion of respondents who would test all OCs regardless of FH or age, as per the recent international guideline, was low (28.2%). The largest hurdles to testing were the cost, as well as the availability of next-generation sequencing-accredited testing and genetic counseling facilities. The panelists suggested that the sequence of somatic testing followed by germline testing may help address both the imminent need of treatment planning and longer term hereditary implications. The potential emotional and financial burdens of BRCAmut testing should be weighed against the potential therapeutic benefits, and the type and timing of testing personalized.
Accessibility of BRCAmut testing to all at-risk individuals will be achievable through improvements in testing affordability, as well as widened availability of accredited testing and genetic counseling facilities.
BRCA基因突变(BRCAmut)检测是乳腺癌(BC)和卵巢癌(OC)风险评估、预防及早期诊断的重要工具,最近还用于确定患者对靶向治疗的易感性。本研究评估了当前BRCAmut检测模式,并探讨医生对检测效用及最佳检测顺序的看法,以促进和规范检测实践。
邀请香港的BC和OC医学专家完成一份关于BRCAmut检测实践的问卷。还召集了一组具有丰富BRCAmut检测经验的专家,采用德尔菲法和匿名电子投票系统就检测制定共识声明。
调查对象(n = 71)认为BC和/或OC的家族史(FH)以及发病年龄早是推荐BRCAmut检测的关键因素。根据最近的国际指南,无论FH或年龄如何都会对所有OC进行检测的受访者比例较低(28.2%)。检测的最大障碍是成本,以及二代测序认证检测和遗传咨询设施的可及性。小组成员建议,先进行体细胞检测再进行种系检测的顺序可能有助于满足治疗计划的紧迫需求以及解决长期的遗传问题。应权衡BRCAmut检测潜在的情感和经济负担与潜在的治疗益处,并使检测类型和时间个性化。
通过提高检测的可承受性以及扩大认证检测和遗传咨询设施的可及范围,所有高危个体都可获得BRCAmut检测。