Shirzadi Zeinab, Rojhani-Shirazi Zahra, Hemmati Ladan
Physiotherapy Department, School of Rehabilitation Sciences, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Fars, Iran.
J Chiropr Med. 2018 Dec;17(4):237-243. doi: 10.1016/j.jcm.2018.04.003. Epub 2019 Jan 21.
The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of scapulothoracic (ST) mobilization plus physical therapy (PT) with PT alone in patients with mechanical neck pain.
This double-blinded randomized clinical trial was conducted at Shiraz School of Rehabilitation Sciences and involved 46 patients with mechanical neck pain and scapular dyskinesia. The patients were randomly assigned to the ST mobilization + PT group (scapulothoracic mobilization and physical therapy) or the PT group (physical therapy treatment) by a computer-generated randomized table of numbers. Both groups received 5 sessions of treatment during 1 week. Pain intensity and grip strength were evaluated 3 times: baseline, after the first session, and after the fifth session. Furthermore, functional disability of the upper limbs and the neck were evaluated before and at the fifth session.
The results showed that the pain intensity was reduced and grip strength increased significantly after the first session ( = .01) and at the end of the treatment ( = .01) in the ST mobilization + PT group in comparison with the PT group. Also, the mean difference of upper limb ( = .01) and neck disability ( = .02) decreased significantly in the ST mobilization + PT group in comparison with the PT group.
Scapulothoracic mobilization in combination with physical therapy may be superior to physical therapy alone in reducing pain intensity, maximizing grip strength, and reducing upper limb and neck disability in mechanical neck pain.
本研究旨在比较肩胛胸壁关节(ST)松动术联合物理治疗(PT)与单纯物理治疗对机械性颈痛患者的疗效。
本双盲随机临床试验在设拉子康复科学学院开展,纳入46例机械性颈痛伴肩胛运动障碍的患者。通过计算机生成的随机数字表将患者随机分为ST松动术+PT组(肩胛胸壁关节松动术和物理治疗)或PT组(物理治疗)。两组均在1周内接受5次治疗。分别在基线、第1次治疗后和第5次治疗后对疼痛强度和握力进行3次评估。此外,在治疗前和第5次治疗时评估上肢和颈部的功能障碍。
结果显示,与PT组相比,ST松动术+PT组在第1次治疗后(P = .01)和治疗结束时(P = .01)疼痛强度降低,握力显著增加。此外,与PT组相比,ST松动术+PT组上肢(P = .01)和颈部功能障碍(P = .02)的平均差异显著降低。
在减轻机械性颈痛患者的疼痛强度、最大化握力以及减少上肢和颈部功能障碍方面,肩胛胸壁关节松动术联合物理治疗可能优于单纯物理治疗。