Department of Sociology, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.
Department of Sociology, Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
PLoS One. 2019 Mar 19;14(3):e0213716. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0213716. eCollection 2019.
Cultural behaviors are theoretically linked to future life chances but empirical literature is scant. We use heavy metal as an example of cultural identities due to its high salience. We first assess the social morphology of metal preferences in terms of socio-economic and socio-structural positions, and then asses the short term outcomes of being a heavy metal fan on education and health behaviors.
The analysis was based on a representative random stratified sample of 23-year-olds of native Swedish, Iranian, and Yugoslavian background in contemporary Sweden (n = 2,232). Linear probability models with multiple imputation were used to calculate preferences for metal music and the association of metal preferences with subsequent outcomes.
In contrast to many prior studies, we find that the preference for heavy metal is not structured by social background or neighborhood context in Swedish adolescents. Poor school grades tend to make them more prone to like metal, but net of previous grades, social background, personality, personal network, and neighborhood characteristics, metal fans have substantially lower transition rates into higher education.
The study suggest that metal preferences appears rather unsystematically with few important predictors, and is linked to lower education attainments in the short run. While these findings are specific to heavy metal as a certain type of culture and to Swedish adolescents, we suggest that they are indicative of how cultural consumption may play a role for life-chances.
文化行为与未来的生活机会在理论上是相关的,但实证文献却很少。我们以重金属为例,因为它具有很高的显著性,是文化认同的一种表现。我们首先评估金属偏好的社会形态,包括社会经济和社会结构地位,然后评估作为重金属迷对教育和健康行为的短期影响。
该分析基于当代瑞典具有代表性的、随机分层的、具有原籍为瑞典、伊朗和南斯拉夫背景的 23 岁人群(n=2232)的随机抽样。我们使用多元插补的线性概率模型来计算对金属音乐的偏好,以及金属偏好与随后的结果之间的关联。
与许多先前的研究不同,我们发现,在瑞典青少年中,重金属的偏好不是由社会背景或邻里环境决定的。成绩差往往使他们更容易喜欢金属,但在扣除以前的成绩、社会背景、个性、个人网络和邻里特征后,重金属迷进入高等教育的比例明显较低。
该研究表明,金属偏好似乎没有什么系统性,也没有什么重要的预测因素,而且在短期内与较低的教育程度有关。虽然这些发现是针对重金属作为一种特定类型的文化以及瑞典青少年的,但我们认为它们表明了文化消费可能对生活机会产生影响。