Institute of Immunization and Prevention, Zhejiang Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Hangzhou 310000, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2019 Mar 18;16(6):957. doi: 10.3390/ijerph16060957.
: Although recall-based data are collected by survey when the vaccination records are not available, the preferred estimates remain the record-based ones due to the limited validity of recall-based data. However, the evidence on validity of maternal recalls is limited and varied across vaccine types. To close the gaps, we validated the maternal recall on vaccination against record-based data in six districts in Zhejiang Province, China. : We used a cross-sectional survey of about 648 households with mothers who delivered in the last 12 months prior to the survey in October 2017, from six districts in Zhejiang Province. Vaccination status on five vaccine types scheduled before 12 months of age were collected through maternal recall and vaccination records. The level of agreement and recall bias between the two resources, the sensitivity and specificity of maternal recall were evaluated. Risk factors for maternal recall bias were also identified through logistic regression model for each type of vaccine. : The level of agreement between recall and record was above 90% across vaccine types, with the recall bias ranged from 2.2% to 9.7%. Recall bias due to over-reporting was slightly higher than that due to under-reporting. Recall bias was positively associated with high parity, home delivery, younger mothers, mothers with low education, and migrant mothers. : This study indicated most of the vaccination status across vaccine types was accurately identified through maternal recall and supported the use of maternal recall to estimate the vaccination coverage as an alternative in the absence of record-based data.
虽然在无法获得疫苗接种记录时可以通过调查收集基于回忆的数据,但由于基于回忆的数据有效性有限,首选的估计仍然是基于记录的数据。然而,关于母体回忆有效性的证据有限,并且因疫苗类型而异。为了弥补这些差距,我们在中国浙江省的六个地区,基于记录的数据验证了针对疫苗接种的母体回忆。
我们使用了 2017 年 10 月在浙江省六个地区进行的一项横断面调查,该调查涉及约 648 户在调查前 12 个月内分娩的母亲。通过母体回忆和疫苗接种记录收集了五种在 12 个月前计划接种的疫苗的接种状况。评估了两种资源之间的一致性和回忆偏倚程度、母体回忆的敏感性和特异性。还通过逻辑回归模型确定了每种疫苗的母体回忆偏倚的危险因素。
回忆和记录之间的一致性在各种疫苗类型中均高于 90%,回忆偏倚范围从 2.2%到 9.7%。由于过度报告引起的回忆偏倚略高于由于报告不足引起的回忆偏倚。回忆偏倚与高胎次、家庭分娩、年轻母亲、低教育程度的母亲和移民母亲呈正相关。
本研究表明,通过母体回忆可以准确识别大多数疫苗接种状况,并且在没有基于记录的数据时,支持使用母体回忆来估计疫苗接种覆盖率作为替代方法。