Smits Marleen, Langelaan Maaike, de Groot Janke, Wagner Cordula
From the Nivel, Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research, Utrecht.
J Patient Saf. 2021 Jun 1;17(4):282-289. doi: 10.1097/PTS.0000000000000586.
To improve patient safety and possibly prevent mortality from adverse events (AEs) in hospitals, it is important to gain insight in their underlying causes. We aimed to examine root causes and potential prevention strategies of AEs in deceased hospital patients.
Data on 571 AEs were used from two retrospective patient record review studies of patients who died during hospitalization in the Netherlands. Trained reviewers assessed contributing factors and potential prevention strategies. The results were analyzed together with data on preventability of the AE and the relationship of the AE with the death of the patient.
In 47% of the AEs, patient-related causes were identified, in 35% human causes, in 9% organizational causes, and in 3% technical causes. Preventable AEs were caused by technical, organizational, and human causes (78%, 74%, and 74%, respectively) more often than by patient-related causes (33%). In addition, technical factors caused AEs leading to preventable death (78%) relatively often. Recommended strategies to prevent AEs were quality assurance/peer review, evaluation of safety behavior, improving procedures, and improving information and communication structures.
Human failures played an important role in the causation of AEs in Dutch hospitals, because they occurred frequently and they were frequently the cause of preventable AEs. To a lesser extent, latent organizational and technical factors were identified. Patient-related factors were often identified, but the preventability of the AEs with these causes was low. For future research into causes of AEs, we recommend combining record review with interviewing.
为提高患者安全并可能预防医院不良事件(AE)导致的死亡,深入了解其潜在原因至关重要。我们旨在研究荷兰医院死亡患者中不良事件的根本原因及潜在预防策略。
使用了两项回顾性患者病历审查研究中的571例不良事件数据,这些研究针对的是在荷兰住院期间死亡的患者。经过培训的审查人员评估了促成因素和潜在预防策略。将结果与不良事件可预防性数据以及不良事件与患者死亡之间的关系数据一起进行分析。
在47%的不良事件中,确定了与患者相关的原因,35%为人为原因,9%为组织原因,3%为技术原因。可预防的不良事件由技术、组织和人为原因导致的频率更高(分别为78%、74%和74%),而由与患者相关的原因导致的频率为33%。此外,技术因素相对频繁地导致了可预防死亡的不良事件(78%)。推荐的预防不良事件的策略包括质量保证/同行评审、安全行为评估、改进程序以及改善信息和沟通结构。
人为失误在荷兰医院不良事件的发生中起重要作用,因为它们频繁发生且常常是可预防不良事件的原因。在较小程度上,发现了潜在的组织和技术因素。经常确定与患者相关的因素,但由这些原因导致的不良事件的可预防性较低。对于未来不良事件原因的研究,我们建议将病历审查与访谈相结合。