Himmelstein D U, Woolhandler S
Int J Health Serv. 1986;16(3):339-54. doi: 10.2190/03FK-FN53-2P5B-ERD5.
Despite growing concern with cost containment, most health policy analysts have ignored vast potential savings on medically irrelevant spending for excess administration, profits, high physician incomes, marketing, and legal involvement in medicine. Indeed, many recent reforms encourage administrative hypertrophy, entrepreneurialism and litigation. A universal national health program could abolish billing and consequently the need for much of the administrative apparatus of health care, and decrease spending for profits and marketing. In this article we analyze the administrative savings that could be realized from instituting a Canadian-style national health insurance program or a national health service similar to that in Britain, and the potential savings from additional reforms to curtail profits, marketing and litigation. Our calculations based on 1983 data suggest that national health insurance would save $42.6 billion annually: $29.2 billion on health administration and insurance overhead, $4.9 billion on profits, $3.9 billion on marketing, and $4.6 billion on physician's incomes. A national health service would save $65.8 billion: $38.4 billion on health administration and insurance overhead, $4.9 billion on profits, $3.9 billion on marketing, and $18.6 billion on physician's incomes. Complete nationalization of all health related industries and reform of the malpractice system would save at least $87.2 billion per year. We conclude that a national health program, in addition to improving access to health care for the oppressed, could achieve cost containment without rationing of care.
尽管人们越来越关注成本控制,但大多数卫生政策分析师都忽视了在医疗管理、利润、医生高收入、营销以及医药领域的法律事务等与医疗无关的支出方面存在的巨大潜在节省空间。事实上,最近的许多改革都鼓励行政机构膨胀、企业化经营和诉讼。一项全民国家健康计划可以废除计费制度,从而消除医疗保健行政机构的许多需求,并减少利润和营销方面的支出。在本文中,我们分析了实施加拿大式国家医疗保险计划或类似于英国的国家医疗服务体系可能实现的行政节省,以及通过进一步改革以削减利润、营销和诉讼所带来的潜在节省。我们基于1983年数据的计算表明,国家医疗保险每年可节省426亿美元:其中292亿美元用于医疗管理和保险费用,49亿美元用于利润,39亿美元用于营销,46亿美元用于医生收入。国家医疗服务体系可节省658亿美元:其中384亿美元用于医疗管理和保险费用,49亿美元用于利润,39亿美元用于营销,186亿美元用于医生收入。将所有与健康相关的行业完全国有化并改革医疗事故制度每年至少可节省872亿美元。我们得出结论,一项国家健康计划,除了能改善弱势群体获得医疗保健的机会外,还能在不实行医疗配给的情况下实现成本控制。