Acharya Bharat Sharma, Blanco-Canqui Humberto, Mitchell Robert B, Cruse Richard, Laird David
J Environ Qual. 2019 Mar;48(2):485-492. doi: 10.2134/jeq2018.10.0380.
Information on the water quality impact of perennial warm-season grasses (WSGs) when grown in marginal lands as dedicated energy crops is limited. We studied how WSGs affected runoff, sediment, and nutrient losses and related near-surface soil properties to those of no-till corn ( L.) on an eroded soil in southwestern Iowa and a center pivot corner in east-central Nebraska. The experiment at the eroded soil was established in 2012, and treatments included 'Liberty' switchgrass ( L.) and no-till continuous corn. The experiment at the pivot corner was established in 2013 with 'Liberty' switchgrass, 'Shawnee' switchgrass, low-diversity grass mixture, and corn. We simulated rainfall at 63.5 ± 2.8 mm h for 1 h to portray 5-yr return periods and measured water erosion in spring 2017. Time to runoff start and runoff depth did not differ between WSGs and corn. On the eroded soil, sediment and nutrient losses did not differ between treatments. At the pivot corner, sediment (0.71 vs. 0.15 Mg ha) and PO-P (0.037 vs. 0.006 kg ha) losses were five times higher in corn than in WSGs. Near-surface soil properties did not differ on the eroded soil, but at the pivot corner, wet aggregate stability was four times higher and residue cover was 34% higher in WSGs than in corn. Water-stable aggregates were negatively correlated with NO-N and PO-P losses. Overall, WSGs can improve water quality in marginally productive croplands, but their effectiveness appears to be site specific.
关于多年生暖季型禾本科植物(WSGs)作为专用能源作物种植在边际土地上对水质影响的信息有限。我们研究了WSGs对径流、泥沙和养分流失的影响,并将爱荷华州西南部侵蚀土壤和内布拉斯加州中东部中心支轴角落处免耕玉米的近地表土壤性质与之进行了比较。2012年在侵蚀土壤上开展了试验,处理包括‘Liberty’柳枝稷(Panicum virgatum L.)和免耕连作玉米。2013年在支轴角落处开展了试验,处理有‘Liberty’柳枝稷、‘Shawnee’柳枝稷、低多样性禾本科植物混合物和玉米。我们模拟了63.5±2.8毫米/小时的降雨,持续1小时以描绘5年一遇的降雨情况,并在2017年春季测量了水蚀情况。WSGs和玉米之间径流开始时间和径流深度没有差异。在侵蚀土壤上,各处理间泥沙和养分流失没有差异。在支轴角落处,玉米的泥沙(0.71对0.15公吨/公顷)和有效磷(0.037对0.006千克/公顷)流失比WSGs高五倍。在侵蚀土壤上近地表土壤性质没有差异,但在支轴角落处,WSGs的湿团聚体稳定性比玉米高四倍,残茬覆盖率比玉米高34%。水稳性团聚体与硝态氮和有效磷流失呈负相关。总体而言,WSGs可以改善边际农田的水质,但其有效性似乎因地点而异。