Department of Preventive Veterinary Medicine and Animal Health, School of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Science, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Transbound Emerg Dis. 2019 Jul;66(4):1693-1700. doi: 10.1111/tbed.13204. Epub 2019 May 8.
Dog rabies and human rabies transmitted by dogs can be prevented through adequate dog vaccination coverage. For surveillance purposes, this coverage must be calculated using accurate population size estimates to avoid misleading conclusions. We used data from a Brazilian national survey comprising 64,348 households, to calculate point estimates and confidence intervals of the size, household density, and rabies vaccination coverage of the owned-dog population in Brazilian federative units. We also evaluated the precision of owned-dog population size estimates, based on the extrapolation among different areas, of the mean number of dogs per household and the human/dog ratio. The estimated owned-dog population size in Brazil was 52,198,324 (95% CI = 51,028,583-53,368,066) and the dog vaccination coverage was 80.09% (95% CI = 79.09%-81.09%). Both estimates had marked variation across Brazilian federative units and urban/rural strata. Only two of the 27 federative units had a confidence interval in rural vaccination coverage above 70% and six did not pass this threshold in their urban stratum. For the first time, we reported probabilistic estimates for an entire country and its main administrative areas. The estimated coverage for the country was high because the most populated federative unit also had high coverage. The mean number of dogs per household and the human/dog ratio were useful as survey estimates to characterize owned-dog density. However, the simple extrapolation of these parameters resulted in estimates of owned-dog population sizes with large errors (up to 254%) that must be interpreted with caution to avoid misleading conclusions. To evaluate the dog population size, we recommend the use of probabilistic sampling designs instead of simple human/dog ratio extrapolations, and the inclusion of animal-related questions in censuses and national surveys to obtain reliable estimates to support improvements in animal and human health.
通过充分的犬疫苗接种覆盖率,可以预防犬传播的狂犬病和人类狂犬病。出于监测目的,必须使用准确的人口规模估计值来计算这种覆盖率,以避免得出误导性的结论。我们使用了一项巴西全国调查的数据,该调查涵盖了 64348 户家庭,以计算巴西联邦单位中犬的规模、家庭密度和狂犬病疫苗接种覆盖率的点估计值和置信区间。我们还评估了根据不同地区的家庭平均犬只数量和人与犬的比例外推得出的犬只数量估计值的精度。巴西估计的犬只数量为 52198324 只(95%CI=51028583-53368066),犬疫苗接种覆盖率为 80.09%(95%CI=79.09%-81.09%)。这两个估计值在巴西联邦单位和城市/农村地区之间都有显著差异。在农村地区,只有两个联邦单位的疫苗接种覆盖率的置信区间超过 70%,而在城市地区,有六个联邦单位没有达到这一阈值。这是我们首次对整个国家及其主要行政区域报告概率估计值。由于人口最多的联邦单位也具有高覆盖率,因此该国的估计覆盖率较高。家庭平均犬只数量和人与犬的比例是有用的调查估计值,可以用来描述犬的密度。然而,这些参数的简单外推会导致犬只数量的估计值存在较大误差(高达 254%),在解释这些估计值时必须谨慎,以避免得出误导性的结论。为了评估犬只数量,我们建议使用概率抽样设计,而不是简单的人与犬比例外推,并且在人口普查和全国性调查中纳入与动物有关的问题,以获得可靠的估计值,从而支持改善动物和人类的健康。