School of Medicine, The University of Notre Dame Australia, PO Box 1225, Fremantle, WA, 6959, Australia.
Fiona Stanley Hospital, 11 Robin Warren Dr, Murdoch, WA, 6150, Australia.
J Cancer Educ. 2020 Aug;35(4):760-765. doi: 10.1007/s13187-019-01526-1.
Despite cancer being the leading cause of mortality, cancer education and patient exposure are lacking in many medical schools. The aim of this study was to evaluate the nature of cancer patient exposure, relative to the clinical setting for medical students on placement and to explore their experiences. Participants were asked to maintain a logbook of cancer patient encounters and were invited to attend a structured focus group upon completion of the academic year. Eleven students submitted logbooks (rr = 6.15%) and eight participated in the focus groups (4.47%). A total of 247 cancer patient encounters were recorded. Third-year students primarily saw cancer patients in surgery (18.62%) and general practice (8.50%), whilst final year students saw cancer patients most frequently in palliative care (35.22%) and ENT surgery (13.77%). Students highlighted that the quality of their interactions with cancer patients varied significantly between clinical settings. Outpatient clinics and surgical in-patients had the lowest level of interaction, with students having a predominantly observatory role. Repeated themes of uncertainty and awkwardness regarding history, examination and discussing death and dying were outcomes of the thematic analysis. Exposure to cancer patients remains highly variable and opportunistic. Students voiced concerns for preparedness to practice and many found it worrisome that they will likely examine a primary cancer when they have graduated, without having done so during their training. Our study suggests that a more structured approach to teaching and clinical exposure to cancer patients is required.
尽管癌症是导致死亡的主要原因,但许多医学院校在癌症教育和患者接触方面都存在不足。本研究旨在评估医学生实习期间接触癌症患者的情况,并探讨他们的体验。要求参与者记录癌症患者的接触情况,并在学年结束后邀请他们参加结构化焦点小组。11 名学生提交了日志(rr=6.15%),8 名学生参加了焦点小组(4.47%)。共记录了 247 次癌症患者的接触。三年级学生主要在外科(18.62%)和普通科(8.50%)看到癌症患者,而最后一年的学生则在姑息治疗(35.22%)和耳鼻喉科手术(13.77%)中最常看到癌症患者。学生们强调,他们与癌症患者的互动质量在不同的临床环境中差异很大。门诊和外科住院部的互动程度最低,学生主要扮演观察角色。主题分析的结果是出现了关于病史、检查以及讨论死亡和临终的不确定性和尴尬感等反复出现的主题。接触癌症患者的情况仍然高度可变且机会性强。学生们对实践准备表示担忧,许多人担心他们毕业后可能会检查原发性癌症,但在培训期间没有这样做。我们的研究表明,需要更有组织的方法来教授和临床接触癌症患者。