Department of Public Policy, University of North Carolina-Charlotte, Charlotte, North Carolina.
Department of Public Health Sciences, University of North Carolina-Charlotte, Charlotte, North Carolina.
Am J Prev Med. 2019 Jun;56(6):882-893. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2019.01.006. Epub 2019 Apr 17.
The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) is a food assistance program that helps Americans afford a healthy diet. However, its influence on children's weight status is unclear. This review examined the evidence of the relationship between SNAP participation and child weight.
The following databases were searched: PubMed, EconLit, Web of Science, and the U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service. The last search was performed in October 2018. This systematic review gives a narrative synthesis of included studies.
Twenty-three studies that examined the weight outcomes of children aged 2-18 years and SNAP participation were included. Eleven studies found no significant relationship between SNAP and child weight outcomes. Nine found that SNAP participation was associated with increased weight outcomes in certain subpopulations, and four found that SNAP was linked to a predicted decrease in weight outcomes in some subpopulations. However, many of these studies did not address a key methodologic challenge: self-selection. Of those that did, five found that SNAP participation was associated with an increased risk of being overweight and elevated weight in certain subpopulations.
SNAP participation may help boys maintain a healthy body weight but can be a contributing factor in being overweight or obese in girls who are long-term participants, or who are already overweight. Food security and participation in multiple food assistance programs may be important modifiers. These findings are relevant to policymakers who are considering reducing SNAP funding or restructuring the program. Further research that utilizes strong designs is needed.
补充营养援助计划(SNAP)是一项帮助美国人负担得起健康饮食的食品援助计划。然而,其对儿童体重状况的影响尚不清楚。本综述考察了 SNAP 参与度与儿童体重之间关系的证据。
以下数据库进行了搜索:PubMed、EconLit、Web of Science 和美国农业部经济研究局。最后一次搜索是在 2018 年 10 月进行的。本系统综述对纳入的研究进行了叙述性综合。
纳入了 23 项研究,这些研究检查了年龄在 2-18 岁的儿童的体重结果和 SNAP 参与度。11 项研究发现 SNAP 与儿童体重结果之间没有显著关系。9 项研究发现 SNAP 参与度与某些亚人群中体重增加结果有关,4 项研究发现 SNAP 与某些亚人群中体重预测下降结果有关。然而,许多这些研究没有解决一个关键的方法学挑战:自我选择。其中五项研究发现,在某些亚人群中,SNAP 参与度与超重和体重增加的风险增加有关。
SNAP 参与度可能有助于男孩保持健康的体重,但对于长期参与或已经超重的女孩来说,可能是超重或肥胖的一个促成因素。粮食安全和参与多种粮食援助计划可能是重要的调节因素。这些发现与考虑减少 SNAP 资金或重组该计划的政策制定者有关。需要进一步利用强大设计进行研究。