University of Oklahoma.
Br J Sociol. 2019 Dec;70(5):2133-2165. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.12673. Epub 2019 Apr 19.
Perception of Western governments' hostility to Islam is one of the indicating features of Islamic fundamentalism and, in some cases, is serving as a pull to join extremist groups. In this paper, using data from two waves of a cross-national survey, we investigate what affects European Muslims' opinions about Western governments. We find that residential segregation is associated with perceived hostility of Western governments to Islam. Further, we find that Muslims living in segregated neighbourhoods and enclaves have a higher probability of believing that Western governments are hostile to Islam. National origins of Muslim immigrants have a significant impact, with people from African countries measuring less perceived hostility than others. We also find that education is associated with perceived hostility of Western governments to Islam in a non-linear way. People with the highest and lowest levels of education tend to be less likely to believe that Western governments are hostile to Islam, relative to people with mid-level education. This non-linear effect is best explained by education's differential effects on perceptions of key world events. During the time between 2011 - before ISIS's announcement of its Caliphate in Iraq and Syria - and 2013, subsequent to that announcement, we see a sharp decrease in perception of Western governments' hostility to Islam, particularly among more educated European Muslims. We make the case that this decrease can be attributed, in some ways, to the emergence of ISIS. We discuss our findings in terms of theoretical and policy implications.
西方政府对伊斯兰教的敌意认知是伊斯兰原教旨主义的一个显著特征,在某些情况下,这种敌意认知是加入极端组织的一种吸引力。在本文中,我们使用了来自两次跨国调查的数据,研究了哪些因素影响欧洲穆斯林对西方政府的看法。我们发现居住隔离与西方政府对伊斯兰教的敌意感知有关。此外,我们发现居住在隔离社区和飞地的穆斯林更有可能认为西方政府对伊斯兰教怀有敌意。穆斯林移民的原籍国也有显著影响,来自非洲国家的人比其他人感受到的敌意要小。我们还发现,教育与西方政府对伊斯兰教的敌意感知呈非线性关系。与受过中等教育的人相比,受教育程度最高和最低的人不太可能认为西方政府对伊斯兰教怀有敌意。这种非线性效应可以通过教育对关键世界事件的感知的差异影响来最好地解释。在 2011 年至 ISIS 在伊拉克和叙利亚宣布建立“哈里发国”之间的这段时间,以及 2013 年之后,我们看到欧洲穆斯林对西方政府敌意的感知急剧下降,尤其是那些受教育程度较高的人。我们认为,这种下降在某种程度上可以归因于 ISIS 的出现。我们从理论和政策影响的角度讨论了我们的发现。