Hilkens Nina A, van Asch Charlotte Jj, Rinkel Gabriel Je, Klijn Catharina Jm
Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care, University Medical Center Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Kempenhaeghe, Academic Center for Epileptology, Heeze, The Netherlands.
Eur Stroke J. 2016 Dec;1(4):288-293. doi: 10.1177/2396987316666589. Epub 2016 Aug 26.
It is unknown which patients with non-traumatic isolated intraventricular hemorrhage should undergo angiographic imaging to detect an underlying macrovascular cause and which modality has the highest yield. We studied yield of angiographic examinations in patients with isolated intraventricular hemorrhage.
We reviewed medical records of patients with intraventricular hemorrhage admitted to the University Medical Center Utrecht between 2002 and 2012. We searched PubMed and Embase for studies on angiographic examinations in intraventricular hemorrhage until January 2014. We calculated yield of angiographic imaging and investigated influence of age, hypertension and anticoagulant use with meta-regression analysis.
We identified 39 patients of whom 30 underwent an angiographic study. CTA suggested a macrovascular abnormality in nine patients, which was confirmed by DSA in seven. In the literature, we found 16 studies describing 209 patients. Pooled analysis showed a yield of 58% for DSA (95% CI 48-68%; 147 patients). One small study described the yield of CTA or MRA (0%; 4 patients). Yield of angiographic imaging decreased with increasing age (-2.6%; -5.0 to -0.2 per year increase) but was not affected by history of hypertension (-8.3%; -80.8 to 64.2) or anticoagulant use (-47.1%; -110.3 to 16.1).
The reported yield of DSA in isolated intraventricular hemorrhage is around 50% but varies considerably, probably due to differences in clinical judgment on the need for angiography performance. The yield is higher in younger patients but based on the available data, it is not possible to set age or other criteria for patients in whom DSA can be safely omitted.
对于哪些非创伤性孤立性脑室内出血患者应接受血管造影成像以检测潜在的大血管病因以及哪种检查方式的阳性率最高尚不清楚。我们研究了孤立性脑室内出血患者血管造影检查的阳性率。
我们回顾了2002年至2012年期间入住乌得勒支大学医学中心的脑室内出血患者的病历。我们检索了PubMed和Embase数据库,查找截至2014年1月关于脑室内出血血管造影检查的研究。我们计算了血管造影成像的阳性率,并通过meta回归分析研究了年龄、高血压和抗凝药物使用的影响。
我们确定了39例患者,其中30例接受了血管造影研究。CTA提示9例患者存在大血管异常,DSA证实其中7例。在文献中,我们发现16项研究描述了209例患者。汇总分析显示DSA的阳性率为58%(95%CI 48-68%;147例患者)。一项小型研究描述了CTA或MRA的阳性率(0%;4例患者)。血管造影成像的阳性率随年龄增长而降低(每年增加-2.6%;-5.0至-0.2),但不受高血压病史(-8.3%;-80.8至64.2)或抗凝药物使用(-47.1%;-110.3至16.1)的影响。
报道的DSA在孤立性脑室内出血中的阳性率约为50%,但差异很大,可能是由于血管造影检查必要性临床判断的差异。年轻患者的阳性率较高,但根据现有数据,无法设定可安全省略DSA检查的患者年龄或其他标准。