Department of Sociology, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA.
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine.
Med Care. 2019 Jun;57(6):460-467. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0000000000001123.
Perioperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is frequently used in breast cancer despite unproven benefits. It is unclear whether surgeons' use of breast MRI is associated with the practices of other surgeons to whom they are connected through shared patients.
We conducted a retrospective study using Medicare data to identify physicians providing breast cancer care during 2007-2009 and grouped them into patient-sharing networks. Physician pairs were classified according to their "degree of separation" based on patient-sharing (eg, physician pairs that care for the same patients were separated by 1 degree; pairs that both share patients with another physician but not with each other were separated by 2 degrees). We assessed the association between the MRI use of a surgeon and the practice patterns of surgical colleagues by comparing MRI use in the observed networks with networks with randomly shuffled rates of MRI utilization.
Of the 15,273 patients who underwent surgery during the study period, 28.8% received perioperative MRI. These patients received care from 1806 surgeons in 60 patient-sharing networks; 55.1% of surgeons used MRI. A surgeon was 24.5% more likely to use MRI if they were directly connected to a surgeon who used MRI. This effect decreased to 16.3% for pairs of surgeons separated by 2 degrees, and 0.8% at the third degree of separation.
Surgeons' use of perioperative breast MRI is associated with the practice of surgeons connected to them through patient-sharing; the strength of this association attenuates as the degree of separation increases.
尽管没有证据表明其具有益处,但是围手术期磁共振成像(MRI)在乳腺癌中经常被使用。目前尚不清楚外科医生使用乳房 MRI 是否与他们通过共享患者而联系在一起的其他外科医生的实践相关。
我们使用医疗保险数据进行了一项回顾性研究,以确定在 2007-2009 年期间提供乳腺癌治疗的医生,并将其分为患者共享网络中的群组。根据患者共享情况(例如,照顾相同患者的医生之间的分离度为 1 度;同时与另一位医生共享患者但彼此之间不共享患者的医生之间的分离度为 2 度),对医生对进行分类。我们通过将观察到的网络中的 MRI 使用情况与随机打乱的 MRI 利用率网络进行比较,评估了外科医生的 MRI 使用情况与外科同事的实践模式之间的关联。
在研究期间接受手术的 15273 名患者中,有 28.8%接受了围手术期 MRI。这些患者由 60 个患者共享网络中的 1806 名外科医生提供治疗;其中 55.1%的外科医生使用了 MRI。如果外科医生与使用 MRI 的外科医生直接相连,则他们使用 MRI 的可能性增加 24.5%。这种影响在分离度为 2 度的外科医生对中降低至 16.3%,而在分离度为 3 度的外科医生中降低至 0.8%。
外科医生使用围手术期乳房 MRI 与通过患者共享与他们联系在一起的外科医生的实践相关;这种关联的强度随着分离度的增加而减弱。