Brinkmann Rory, Turner Andrew, Podolsky Scott H
Perspect Biol Med. 2019;62(1):41-71. doi: 10.1353/pbm.2019.0003.
Originating within astronomy as a technical term in the first half of the 18th century, the term "personal equation" spread into a litany of other fields including medicine, where it was used widely and variously from the late 19th century to the middle of the 20th century. We explore the personal equation in the medical literatures of the United States and Britain through a systematic analysis of over 700 articles in four prominent medical journals in conjunction with additional relevant source materials. After tracing the term's dispersion from astronomy into medically allied fields, we examine its striking polysemy while using its rich usage as a lens to examine prevailing tensions within contemporary American and British medicine. Stretching from patient and clinician variability to observer variability and error, the personal equation's various meanings reflect debates about the art and science of medical care that persist into the present day.
“个人因素”一词最初是18世纪上半叶天文学中的一个专业术语,后来传播到包括医学在内的一系列其他领域,在19世纪末到20世纪中叶被广泛且多样地使用。我们通过系统分析四种著名医学期刊上的700多篇文章以及其他相关资料来源,来探究美国和英国医学文献中的个人因素。在追溯该术语从天文学传播到医学相关领域之后,我们考察了它显著的一词多义现象,同时将其丰富的用法作为一个视角,来审视当代英美医学中普遍存在的紧张关系。从患者和临床医生的个体差异到观察者的差异和误差,个人因素的各种含义反映了关于医疗护理的艺术与科学的争论,这些争论一直持续到今天。