School of Applied Psychology, Griffith University, Queensland, 4122, Australia.
Scandy Statistical Modelling Pty Ltd, Blackmans Bay, Australia.
J Abnorm Child Psychol. 2019 Nov;47(11):1821-1840. doi: 10.1007/s10802-019-00551-4.
Many children experience anxiety but have limited access to empirically-supported interventions. School-based interventions using brief, computer-assisted training provide a viable way of reaching children. Recent evidence suggests that computer-delivered 'positive search training' (PST) reduces anxiety in children. This multi-informant, randomised controlled trial compared classroom-based, computer-delivered PST (N = 116) to a classroom-based, therapist-delivered cognitive-behavioural intervention (CBI) (N = 127) and a curriculum-as-usual control condition (CAU) (N = 60) in 7-11 year old children. Primary outcomes were child and parent report of child anxiety symptoms. Secondary outcomes were child and parent report of child depressive symptoms and child attention biases. Outcomes were assessed before and after the interventions, and six- and 12-months post-intervention. Teacher report of children's social-emotional functioning was assessed at pre- and post-intervention. As expected, compared to CAU, children receiving PST and the CBI reported greater anxiety reductions by post-intervention and six-month follow-up but, unexpectedly, not at 12-month follow-up. Partially consistent with hypotheses, compared to CAU, parents reported greater anxiety reductions in children receiving PST, but not the CBI, at 12-month follow-up. Contrary to expectation, there was a pre- to post-intervention increase in threat attention bias in PST compared to the other conditions, with no significant differences at follow-up. In support of hypotheses, teachers reported higher post-intervention social-emotional functioning in Year 5 students receiving the CBI but, unexpectedly, lower post-intervention functioning in students receiving PST. There were no effects on depressive symptoms. Further research is needed on strategies to maintain long-term benefits and determine preventative versus early intervention effects.
许多儿童经历焦虑,但获得实证支持的干预措施有限。基于学校的干预措施,使用简短的计算机辅助培训,为接触儿童提供了一种可行的方法。最近的证据表明,计算机提供的“积极搜索训练”(PST)可减少儿童的焦虑。这项多信息来源、随机对照试验比较了基于课堂的、计算机提供的 PST(N = 116)与基于课堂的、治疗师提供的认知行为干预(CBI)(N = 127)以及常规课程对照条件(CAU)(N = 60)在 7-11 岁儿童中的效果。主要结果是儿童和家长报告的儿童焦虑症状。次要结果是儿童和家长报告的儿童抑郁症状和儿童注意力偏向。在干预前后以及干预后 6 个月和 12 个月进行了评估。在干预前和干预后评估了教师报告的儿童社交情感功能。如预期的那样,与 CAU 相比,接受 PST 和 CBI 的儿童在干预后和 6 个月随访时报告的焦虑程度降低,但在 12 个月随访时并非如此。部分符合假设的是,与 CAU 相比,接受 PST 的父母报告的儿童焦虑程度降低,但 CBI 则不然,在 12 个月随访时没有差异。与预期相反,与其他条件相比,PST 中的威胁注意偏向在干预前到干预后增加,而在随访时没有显著差异。支持假设的是,教师报告说,接受 CBI 的五年级学生在干预后具有更高的社交情感功能,但出乎意料的是,接受 PST 的学生在干预后功能较低。对抑郁症状没有影响。需要进一步研究维持长期效益的策略,并确定预防与早期干预的效果。