Yoo Sang Gune K, Davies Divin, Mohanan Padinhare P, Baldridge Abigail S, Charles Prakash M, Schumacher Mark, Bhalla Sandeep, Devarajan Raji, Hirschhorn Lisa R, Prabhakaran Dorairaj, Huffman Mark D
Department of Preventive Medicine, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL (S.G.K.Y., A.S.B., M.D.H.).
WestFort Hi-Tech Hospital Ltd, Thrissur, India (D.D., P.P.M.).
Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes. 2019 May;12(5):e005251. doi: 10.1161/CIRCOUTCOMES.118.005251.
Background Hospital management practices are associated with cardiovascular process of care measures and patient outcomes. However, management practices related to acute cardiac care in India has not been studied. Methods and Results We measured management practices through semistructured, in-person interviews with hospital administrators, physician managers, and nurse managers in Kerala, India between October and November 2017 using the adapted World Management Survey. Trained interviewers independently scored management interview responses (range: 1-5) to capture management practices ranging from performance data tracking to setting targets. We performed univariate regression analyses to assess the relationship between hospital-level factors and management practices. Using Pearson correlation coefficients and mixed-effect logistic regression models, we explored the relationship between management practices and 30-day major adverse cardiovascular events defined as all-cause mortality, reinfarction, stroke, or major bleeding. Ninety managers from 37 hospitals participated. We found suboptimal management practices across 3 management levels (mean [SD]: 2.1 [0.5], 2.0 [0.3], and 1.9 [0.3] for hospital administrators, physician managers, and nurse managers, respectively [ P=0.08]) with lowest scores related to setting organizational targets. Hospitals with existing healthcare quality accreditation, more cardiologists, and private ownership were associated with higher management scores. In our exploratory analysis, higher physician management practice scores related to operation, performance, and target management were correlated with lower 30-day major adverse cardiovascular event. Conclusions Management practices related to acute cardiac care in participating Kerala hospitals were suboptimal but were correlated with clinical outcomes. We identified opportunities to strengthen nonclinical practices to improve patient care.
背景 医院管理实践与心血管护理流程措施及患者预后相关。然而,印度急性心脏护理相关的管理实践尚未得到研究。方法与结果 2017年10月至11月期间,我们在印度喀拉拉邦通过与医院管理人员、内科医师管理人员和护士管理人员进行半结构化的面对面访谈,采用改编后的世界管理调查来衡量管理实践。经过培训的访谈者对管理访谈的回答进行独立评分(范围:1 - 5),以获取从绩效数据跟踪到设定目标等管理实践情况。我们进行单变量回归分析以评估医院层面因素与管理实践之间的关系。使用Pearson相关系数和混合效应逻辑回归模型,我们探讨了管理实践与30天主要不良心血管事件(定义为全因死亡率、再梗死、中风或大出血)之间的关系。来自37家医院的90名管理人员参与了研究。我们发现三个管理层面的管理实践均未达到最佳水平(医院管理人员、内科医师管理人员和护士管理人员的平均[标准差]分别为2.1[0.5]、2.0[0.3]和1.9[0.3][P = 0.08]),与设定组织目标相关的得分最低。拥有现有医疗质量认证、更多心脏病专家和私立性质的医院管理得分更高。在我们的探索性分析中,与运营、绩效和目标管理相关的内科医师管理实践得分较高与30天主要不良心血管事件发生率较低相关。结论 参与研究的喀拉拉邦医院中与急性心脏护理相关的管理实践未达到最佳水平,但与临床结局相关。我们确定了加强非临床实践以改善患者护理的机会。