J Sport Rehabil. 2020 Jan 1;29(1):122-126. doi: 10.1123/jsr.2018-0224.
Clinical Scenario: A sport-related concussion is a common injury to the brain that may cause a variety of symptoms ranging in duration and severity. The mainstay of treatment for concussion has been rest, followed by a stepwise return to activity. This recovery process may be lengthy when symptoms persist. Aerobic exercise conducted at subsymptom and submaximal intensities has been proposed as a potential intervention for symptoms following a concussion. Therefore, the purpose of this critically appraised topic is to examine the safety of varying aerobic exercise intensities in patients with a concussion. Focused Clinical Question: Are subsymptom and submaximal exercise programs safe when implemented in a population with a symptomatic sports-related concussion when compared with traditional rest? Summary of Key Findings: Four randomized controlled trials were included for critical appraisal. The 4 studies investigated supervised and controlled aerobic exercise as early as within 1 week of with a concussion; all studies conclude that exercise is safe and may be of benefit to individuals with a concussion. Two studies support the use of submaximal exercise as a therapeutic intervention for adolescents with persistent concussion symptoms. Clinical Bottom Line: The authors conclude that controlled exercise performed within the symptom or exertion threshold of patients with concussion is safe compared with rest. It was noted that symptom changes may occur; however, the changes did not have a negative impact on long-term recovery. This research should ease concerns about prescribing physical activity when an athlete with concussion is still experiencing lingering symptoms. While specific parameters of the activity performed have not been described in detail, the individualization of each exercise program was stressed. Strength of Recommendation: Grade A.
运动相关性脑震荡是一种常见的脑部损伤,可能导致各种症状,其持续时间和严重程度不一。脑震荡的主要治疗方法是休息,然后逐步恢复活动。当症状持续存在时,康复过程可能会很长。在亚症状和亚最大强度下进行有氧运动已被提议作为脑震荡后症状的潜在干预措施。因此,本关键性评价主题旨在检查在有症状的运动相关性脑震荡患者中,采用不同有氧运动强度的安全性。
与传统休息相比,在有症状的运动相关性脑震荡人群中实施亚症状和亚最大运动方案是否安全?
有 4 项随机对照试验被纳入批判性评价。这 4 项研究调查了在脑震荡后 1 周内进行的监督和控制的有氧运动;所有研究都得出结论,运动是安全的,可能对脑震荡患者有益。有两项研究支持使用亚最大运动作为青少年持续脑震荡症状的治疗干预措施。
作者得出结论,与休息相比,在脑震荡患者的症状或用力阈值内进行的受控运动是安全的。虽然可能会发生症状变化,但这些变化对长期恢复没有负面影响。当运动员仍有挥之不去的症状时,这项研究应该减轻对进行身体活动的担忧。虽然没有详细描述所进行的活动的具体参数,但强调了每个运动方案的个体化。
A级。