Department of Neurology, Geetanjali Medical College and Hospital, Udaipur, Rajasthan, India.
Department of Neurology, Central India Institute of Medical Sciences, Nagpur, Maharashtra, India.
Seizure. 2019 Jul;69:245-250. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2019.05.007. Epub 2019 May 14.
To prospectively assess the feasibility of establishing low cost epilepsy surgery programs in resource poor settings.
We started epilepsy surgery centers in Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities in India in private hospitals. This model is based on the identifying and operating ideal epilepsy surgery candidates on the basis of clinical history, interictal and ictal video-EEG data, and 1.5 T MRI without other investigations and without regular involvement of other specialists. Trained epileptologists formed the fulcrum of this program who identified ideal candidates, offered them counseling, and read video-EEG and MRI. We also spread epilepsy awareness among locals and physicians and established focused epilepsy clinics. The expenses were subsidized for deserving patients and policies were devised to keep video-EEG duration and staff requirement to minimum. Difficult epilepsy surgery cases were referred to established centers. Initial surgeries were performed by invited epilepsy surgeons and subsequently by local neurosurgeons.
A total of 125 epilepsy surgeries were performed at three centers since 2012. This included 81(64.8%) temporal lobe resections, 26 (20.8%) extratemporal focal resections, and 13 (10.4%) hemispherotomies. Of the 93 patients with more than 1 year of postoperative followup, 86 (92.5%) had Engel class IA outcome. There were minor complications in 5% patients. Average cost of presurgical evaluation and surgery was Rs. 92,707 (USD 1,324).
It is possible to establish successful epilepsy surgery programs in resource poor setting with reasonable costs. This low cost model can be replicated in other parts of world to reduce the surgical treatment gap.
前瞻性评估在资源匮乏环境中建立低成本癫痫手术项目的可行性。
我们在印度的二级和三级城市的私立医院中建立了癫痫手术中心。该模式基于临床病史、发作间期和发作期视频脑电图数据以及 1.5T MRI 来识别和治疗理想的癫痫手术候选者,无需进行其他检查,也无需定期咨询其他专家。经过培训的癫痫专家是该项目的核心,他们识别理想的候选者,为他们提供咨询,并解读视频脑电图和 MRI。我们还在当地人和医生中开展癫痫宣传活动,并建立了专注的癫痫诊所。为有需要的患者提供费用补贴,并制定政策将视频脑电图的持续时间和人员需求降至最低。复杂的癫痫手术病例则转至已建立的中心。最初的手术由受邀的癫痫外科医生进行,随后由当地神经外科医生进行。
自 2012 年以来,三个中心共进行了 125 例癫痫手术。其中包括 81 例(64.8%)颞叶切除术、26 例(20.8%)额外颞叶焦点切除术和 13 例(10.4%)半球切开术。在 93 例术后随访超过 1 年的患者中,86 例(92.5%)达到 Engel 分级 IA。5%的患者出现轻微并发症。术前评估和手术的平均费用为 92707 卢比(1324 美元)。
在资源匮乏的环境中,以合理的成本建立成功的癫痫手术项目是可行的。这种低成本模式可以在世界其他地区复制,以缩小手术治疗差距。