Brooks Wilson C, Votanopoulos Konstantinos I, Russell Gregory B, Shen Perry, Levine Edward A
Am Surg. 2019 May 1;85(5):505-510.
Chest radiographs (CXRs) and laboratory testing have historically been performed as a part of low-risk melanoma (clinical stage 1/2) workup. This study evaluates the utility of routine CXRs and laboratory testing during the staging of clinical stage 1 and 2 melanoma patients. This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board at Wake Forest University. A database of sentinel lymph node biopsies performed for clinical stage 1 or 2 melanoma was used to identify early-stage melanoma patients. The medical records of patients with melanoma were reviewed and preoperative workup procedures were recorded. Four hundred sixty-three patients were reviewed. A total of 315 patients underwent a preoperative CXR, whereas 309 received some laboratory testing. After sentinel node biopsies, 168 patients had pathologic stage 1 disease, 103 stage 2, and 44 stage 3. None of the CXRs (0%) correctly identified metastatic melanoma. Suspicious locations on CXRs and laboratory testing did not lead to metastatic findings in any patient within a year. Metastatic melanoma was not found in any patient by screening with CXRs or laboratory testing during preoperative workup. We recommend not conducting CXRs or laboratory testing during workup for surgical melanoma patients because of charges and anxiety these tests can cause. CXRs, blood tests, and metabolic panels have historically been ordered for early melanoma patients, although debate remains on their efficacy. Surgical patient records were retrospectively reviewed for these tests and no benefit was found.
胸部X光片(CXR)和实验室检查历来是低风险黑色素瘤(临床1/2期)检查的一部分。本研究评估了常规CXR和实验室检查在临床1期和2期黑色素瘤患者分期中的作用。本研究获得了维克森林大学机构审查委员会的批准。利用为临床1期或2期黑色素瘤进行前哨淋巴结活检的数据库来识别早期黑色素瘤患者。回顾了黑色素瘤患者的病历并记录了术前检查程序。共审查了463例患者。共有315例患者接受了术前CXR检查,而309例接受了一些实验室检查。在前哨淋巴结活检后,168例患者为病理1期疾病,103例为2期,44例为3期。没有一张CXR(0%)能正确识别转移性黑色素瘤。CXR和实验室检查中可疑部位在一年内没有导致任何患者出现转移结果。在术前检查中,通过CXR或实验室检查筛查未发现任何患者有转移性黑色素瘤。由于这些检查可能导致的费用和焦虑,我们建议在手术黑色素瘤患者的检查过程中不进行CXR或实验室检查。尽管关于其疗效仍存在争议,但胸部X光片、血液检查和代谢指标检查历来是为早期黑色素瘤患者开具的。对这些检查的手术患者记录进行了回顾性审查,未发现任何益处。