Xue Jing, Peng Yujing, Zhang Yanan, Chen Weiqi, Pan Yuesong, Qi Yu, Hao Lina, Gu Weibin, Wang Ning, Gao Peiyi
Department of Radiology, Beijing Tiantan Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing 100070, China.
Beijing Neurosurgical Institute, Beijing 100070, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2019 Apr;9(4):615-624. doi: 10.21037/qims.2019.04.05.
Collateral flow is associated with clinical outcomes for patients with Moyamoya disease and served as a parameter for patient selection of therapeutic strategies. Therefore, we explored whether a noninvasive imaging modality, computed tomography perfusion (CTP) source images (CTP-Sis), could be used to identify the presence and intensity of collateral flow using digital subtraction angiography (DSA) as a gold standard for collateral flow.
CTP-Sis and DSA were performed for 24 patients with unilateral Moyamoya disease. A collateral grading system was developed based on arterial and venous phase CTP-Sis, imitating the DSA score system. Two neuroradiologists scored the DSA images using a collateral grading scale for the regions of interest corresponding to the Alberta Stroke Program Early computed tomography Score (ASPECTS) methodology. Another two neuroradiologists scored CTP-Sis in a similar manner. Agreement between the CTP-Sis and DSA consensus scores was determined, including kappa statistics.
The agreement between the CTP-Sis and DSA consensus readings was moderate to strong, with a weighted kappa value of 0.768 [95% confidence interval (CI), 0.703-0.832], but there was a better agreement for readers of CTP-Sis, as compared with those of DSA. The sensitivity and specificity for identifying collaterals with CTP-Sis were 0.714 (95% CI, 0.578-0.851) and 0.995 (95% CI, 0.985-1.000), respectively.
CTP-Sis could help identify in a noninvasive manner the presence and intensity of collateral flow in patients with unilateral Moyamoya disease using DSA as a gold standard. Further study with a large number of cases is warranted. Further application of this method to other cerebrovascular diseases including acute ischemic stroke can also be warranted.
烟雾病患者的侧支循环与临床结局相关,并作为治疗策略患者选择的一个参数。因此,我们探讨了一种非侵入性成像方式,即计算机断层扫描灌注(CTP)源图像(CTP-Sis),是否可用于以数字减影血管造影(DSA)作为侧支循环的金标准来识别侧支循环的存在和强度。
对24例单侧烟雾病患者进行了CTP-Sis和DSA检查。基于动脉期和静脉期CTP-Sis开发了一种侧支分级系统,模仿DSA评分系统。两名神经放射科医生使用与阿尔伯塔卒中项目早期计算机断层扫描评分(ASPECTS)方法相对应的感兴趣区域的侧支分级量表对DSA图像进行评分。另外两名神经放射科医生以类似方式对CTP-Sis进行评分。确定CTP-Sis和DSA共识评分之间的一致性,包括kappa统计量。
CTP-Sis和DSA共识读数之间的一致性为中度至高度,加权kappa值为0.768[95%置信区间(CI),(0.703 - )0.832],但与DSA读者相比,CTP-Sis读者之间的一致性更好。使用CTP-Sis识别侧支循环的敏感性和特异性分别为0.714(95%CI,(0.578 - )0.851)和0.995(95%CI,(0.985 - )1.000)。
以DSA作为金标准,CTP-Sis可以帮助以非侵入性方式识别单侧烟雾病患者侧支循环的存在和强度。有必要进行大量病例的进一步研究。这种方法在包括急性缺血性卒中在内的其他脑血管疾病中的进一步应用也可能是合理的。