Department of Radiology, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Stroke. 2013 Aug;44(8):2194-9. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.111.000675. Epub 2013 Jun 11.
Although collateral vessels have been shown to be an important prognostic factor in acute ischemic stroke, patients with lack of collaterals on standard imaging techniques may still have good clinical outcome. We postulate that in these cases collateral vessels are present though not visible on standard imaging techniques that are based on a single time frame.
This study included 40 consecutive patients with acute ischemic stroke with a large-vessel occlusion. Standard computed tomography angiography (CTA, single time frame) and CT perfusion (multiple time frames) were obtained at admission and timing-invariant (TI)-CTA was created from the CT perfusion data. Clinical outcome data (modified Rankin Scale) were assessed at 3-month follow-up. Four experienced observers independently assessed collateral status twice on both standard CTA and TI-CTA in an independent, blinded, randomized manner. Collateral status was rated as good if ≥50% and poor if <50% of collaterals were present compared with the contralateral hemisphere.
Collateral status was rated higher on TI-CTA (good in 84%) compared with standard CTA (good in 49%; P<0.001). Thirty-one percent of patients with poor collateral status on standard CTA still had good clinical outcome. All of those patients, however, showed good collaterals on TI-CTA. All cases with poor collateral status rated on TI-CTA had poor clinical outcome.
Collateral vessels may not always be visible on standard single time-frame CTA because of delayed contrast arrival. Future prognostic studies in acute stroke should consider delay-insensitive techniques, such as TI-CTA, instead of standard single time-frame imaging, such as standard CTA.
尽管侧支循环已被证明是急性缺血性脑卒中的一个重要预后因素,但在标准影像学技术上无侧支循环的患者仍可能有良好的临床结局。我们假设,在这些情况下,侧支循环虽然在基于单一时间窗的标准影像学技术上不可见,但实际上是存在的。
本研究纳入了 40 例急性大血管闭塞性脑梗死患者。入院时进行标准 CT 血管造影(CTA,单一时间窗)和 CT 灌注(多时间窗)检查,并从 CT 灌注数据中生成时间不变性(TI)-CTA。在 3 个月的随访中评估临床结局数据(改良 Rankin 量表)。4 名有经验的观察者独立、盲法、随机地在标准 CTA 和 TI-CTA 上对侧支循环状态进行两次评估。如果与对侧半球相比,侧支循环存在≥50%(良好)或<50%(不良),则将侧支循环状态评为良好或不良。
TI-CTA 上的侧支循环状态评分(良好 84%)高于标准 CTA(良好 49%;P<0.001)。在标准 CTA 上侧支循环不良的 31%的患者仍有良好的临床结局。然而,这些患者的 TI-CTA 上均显示良好的侧支循环。在 TI-CTA 上评分较差的所有侧支循环不良病例均有较差的临床结局。
由于对比剂到达时间延迟,标准单时间窗 CTA 上可能并非总是能显示侧支循环。未来的急性脑卒中预后研究应考虑延迟不敏感技术,如 TI-CTA,而不是标准单时间窗成像,如标准 CTA。