McGrath G, Lowson K
Department of Psychiatry, University Hospital of South Manchester, UK.
Br J Psychiatry. 1987 Jan;150:65-71. doi: 10.1192/bjp.150.1.65.
Recent debate about the place of psychotherapy in the National Health Service, while emphasising the importance of economic evaluation, has concentrated almost exclusively on issues of clinical outcome. This paper argues that the debate has focussed on too narrow a definition of psychotherapy and too limited a view of the possible effects of psychotherapy, both good and bad. It reviews evidence concerning the demand and need for psychotherapy services in a number of clinical settings, and discusses the economic implications of the provision of such services. Economic studies of psychotherapy are reviewed and a conclusion drawn that it might be possible to justify the provision of psychotherapy services on economic grounds, but that considerably more research needs to be done in this area. The directions such future research might take are outlined.
近期关于心理治疗在国民医疗服务体系中地位的争论,虽强调了经济评估的重要性,但几乎完全集中在临床疗效问题上。本文认为,这场争论所关注的心理治疗定义过于狭隘,对心理治疗可能产生的好坏影响的看法也过于有限。本文回顾了一些临床环境中心理治疗服务的需求和需要的相关证据,并讨论了提供此类服务的经济影响。对心理治疗的经济学研究进行了综述,并得出结论:从经济角度来看,有可能为提供心理治疗服务找到正当理由,但在这一领域还需要进行更多的研究。还概述了未来此类研究可能的方向。