Dept. of Radiology, Medical Physics, Medical Center - University of Freiburg, Faculty of Medicine, University of Freiburg, Germany.
Institute for Fluid Mechanics and Aerodynamics, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Technische Universität Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany.
J Magn Reson. 2019 Aug;305:16-21. doi: 10.1016/j.jmr.2019.05.009. Epub 2019 May 24.
In arterial blood flow wall shear stress (WSS) quantifies the frictional force that flowing blood exerts on a vessel wall. WSS can be directly estimated from phase-contrast (PC) MR velocity measurements and has been suggested as a biomarker in cardio-vascular diseases. We present and investigate the application of the Clauser plot method for estimating WSS in fully developed turbulent stationary flow using PC velocity measurements. The Clauser plot method estimates WSS from the logarithmic region of boundary layer in fully developed turbulent stationary flow. The Clauser plot method was evaluated using 2D PC-MR phantom measurements at 3 T for different in-plane resolutions at various Reynolds numbers. WSS values derived from the Clauser plot were compared to results from Laser Doppler Velocimetry (LDV) measurements and theoretical results calculated using the friction factor formula for smooth pipe flow. For all Reynolds numbers, WSS values derived from the Clauser plot were in good agreement with results from LDV measurements and values using the friction factor formula (relative deviations ∼5%). Furthermore, Clauser plot derived results were almost independent of spatial resolution, in contrast to WSS results obtained with our in-house software tool for MR-based WSS quantification showing relative deviations of more than 100%. In fully developed turbulent flow, the Clauser plot method provides highly consistent WSS independent of the underlying spatial resolution. Therefore, it renders a valuable approach for MR-based WSS estimates in controllable flow settings. Although its direct in vivo applicability is severely limited because of the different flow character, it may serve as helpful approach for validation of MR-based WSS quantification algorithms prior to their clinical application.
在动脉血流中,壁面切应力 (WSS) 量化了流动血液对血管壁施加的摩擦力。WSS 可以直接从相位对比 (PC) MR 速度测量中估计出来,并已被提议作为心血管疾病的生物标志物。我们提出并研究了使用 PC 速度测量估计完全发展的湍流静止流中 WSS 的 Clauser 图方法的应用。Clauser 图方法从完全发展的湍流静止流中的边界层对数区域估计 WSS。Clauser 图方法在 3T 下使用二维 PC-MR 体模测量进行了评估,对于不同的雷诺数,在不同的平面分辨率下进行了评估。从 Clauser 图得出的 WSS 值与激光多普勒速度测量 (LDV) 测量结果以及使用光滑管流摩擦因子公式计算的理论结果进行了比较。对于所有的雷诺数,从 Clauser 图得出的 WSS 值与 LDV 测量结果以及使用摩擦因子公式得出的值非常吻合 (相对偏差约为 5%)。此外,Clauser 图得出的结果几乎与空间分辨率无关,而我们用于基于 MR 的 WSS 量化的内部软件工具得出的结果则显示出 100%以上的相对偏差。在完全发展的湍流中,Clauser 图方法提供了高度一致的 WSS,与潜在的空间分辨率无关。因此,它为可控流环境中的基于 MR 的 WSS 估计提供了一种有价值的方法。尽管由于流动特性的不同,其直接的体内适用性受到严重限制,但它可能作为基于 MR 的 WSS 量化算法在临床应用之前进行验证的有用方法。