Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Oakfield House, Oakfield Road, Bristol, UK.
Department of Public Health, Environments and Society, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, 15-17 Tavistock Place, London, UK.
J Public Health (Oxf). 2020 Aug 18;42(3):610-617. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdz059.
Over 1.2 million 16-18 year-olds are enrolled in further education (FE-advanced secondary education) in England. Life course transitions provide opportunities to change, establish or reinforce health behaviours. FE presents an opportunity for public health improvement, yet few interventions target this setting. Using a smoking prevention intervention, we explore how young people were viewed in FE and how this affected intervention acceptability.
Eleven student and five staff focus groups were conducted in three intervention institutions (two colleges, one school sixth-form), as part of the process evaluation of a smoking prevention feasibility study. FE managers in intervention and control institutions were also interviewed (n = 5). Data were analysed using thematic analysis.
In both colleges and the sixth-form, students were viewed as emergent adults and treated differently from 'school-children', in practice if not in policy. Colleges permitted smoking in designated areas; in the school sixth-form smoking was unofficially tolerated but concealed from younger students. Using staff to deliver anti-smoking messages reintroduced an unwanted power dynamic which disrupted perceptions of students as young adults.
FE is an important setting for young people's health. Understanding the culture and context of FE is critical in designing acceptable and effective public health interventions.
在英国,超过 120 万名 16-18 岁的青少年接受继续教育(FE-高级中等教育)。人生历程的转变提供了改变、建立或加强健康行为的机会。FE 为改善公共卫生提供了机会,但很少有干预措施针对这一环境。我们使用一项预防吸烟的干预措施,探讨了年轻人在 FE 中的形象,以及这如何影响干预措施的可接受性。
作为一项预防吸烟可行性研究的过程评估的一部分,在三个干预机构(两所学院、一所学校六年级)中进行了 11 名学生和 5 名工作人员的焦点小组讨论,干预和对照机构的 FE 管理人员也接受了访谈(n=5)。使用主题分析对数据进行分析。
在两所学院和六年级,学生被视为新兴成年人,与“学童”不同,即使在政策上没有不同,在实践中也是如此。学院允许在指定区域吸烟;在学校六年级,吸烟虽然没有被正式允许,但被隐藏起来不让低年级学生看到。使用工作人员来传递反吸烟信息,重新引入了一种不受欢迎的权力动态,破坏了学生作为成年人的观念。
FE 是年轻人健康的重要环境。了解 FE 的文化和背景对于设计可接受和有效的公共卫生干预措施至关重要。