Zaghloul Nancy M, Megahed Haidy M
Department of Forensic Medicine and Clinical Toxicology, Misr University for Science and Technology, Egypt.
Department of Forensic Medicine and Clinical Toxicology, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2019 Aug;66:25-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2019.05.018. Epub 2019 May 30.
Mortality is conditioned by biological, political and social factors, as well as by culturally defined behaviors and attitudes that historically characterize the stage of development of a country or a region. Women are often in great danger, where they should be safest. Violence against women is the most pervasive yet the least recognized human rights violation in the world. It is a profound health problem and femicide, is often the tragic end-point of violence. Females represent more than half of the Egyptian population, however, they remain vulnerable.
To describe and analyze data obtained from Zeinhom Morgue records in Cairo, regarding female deaths, throughout two years. To evaluate female deaths regarding age, cause, manner of death, location, perpetrator and motive. To describe the incidence of female homicides and their related injury patterns. To identify the risk factors and nature of violence from victimologic point of view. Finally, to describe the manner of death whether natural, homicidal, suicidal or accidental aiming for early identification of vulnerable females so that actions can be taken to prevent further mortality.
This is a national two year retrospective descriptive mortuary based study. The study population comprised of all adult females, aged 18 years and older, whose death was suspicious and medico-legal examination was ordered. Each investigation included a detailed case history, investigation, gross examination, histo-pathological and toxicological examinations. Data was collected from autopsy reports, hospital records and police records. From the available data the victim profile was made.
All female deaths aged 18 years and older were retrospectively reviewed for 2 years at Zeinhom morgue of Medico-legal Authority from a total of 1858 autopsy cases. The most common manner of death was homicide. The commonest cause of death in homicides was due to sharp traumatic injuries. Natural death was the least common manner of death and ischemic heart disease constituted the commonest cause. Falling from height was the most common method of suicidal related deaths. Regarding poisoned cases, insecticides and carbon monoxide were the most common detected poisons. According to the cause of death (trauma), blunt trauma injuries were the most common. Falling from height constituted the largest percent of cases under this group.
Females in the third decade of life with blunt injuries to the head and neck were the majority of adult female autopsies. Homicide was the most common manner of female death using sharp instruments after domestic arguments mainly by a spouse or relative. Accidental death came second mainly due to post-operative complications. In cases of suicide, falling from height was the commonest cause followed by poisoning. These findings could be useful for forensic pathologists and healthcare promoters in predicting and preventing female deaths. Moreover, this emphasizes the need for raising public awareness about the scale of female violence problem in our society. The results of this study indicates that, by not only a strong legal support network, but also by opportunities for economic independency, essential education and awareness, alternative accommodation and a change in attitude and mindset of society, judiciary, legislature, executive, men and most importantly women themselves can lower or even prevent such deaths specially suicidal.
死亡率受到生物、政治和社会因素的制约,也受到具有历史意义的、体现一个国家或地区发展阶段的文化行为和态度的影响。女性往往身处本应最安全却极度危险的境地。暴力侵害妇女行为是世界上最为普遍却最不被认可的人权侵犯行为。这是一个严重的健康问题,而杀害妇女行为往往是暴力行为的悲惨结局。女性占埃及人口的一半以上,但她们仍然易受伤害。
描述和分析从开罗宰因霍姆停尸房记录中获取的关于两年间女性死亡情况的数据。评估女性死亡的年龄、原因、死亡方式、地点、行凶者和动机。描述女性杀人案的发生率及其相关伤害模式。从受害者学角度确定暴力的风险因素和性质。最后,描述死亡方式,无论是自然死亡、他杀、自杀还是意外死亡,以便尽早识别易受伤害的女性,从而采取行动防止更多死亡事件发生。
这是一项基于全国范围的、为期两年的回顾性描述性停尸房研究。研究人群包括所有18岁及以上成年女性,其死亡情况可疑且已下令进行法医检查。每次调查都包括详细的病史、调查、大体检查、组织病理学和毒理学检查。数据从尸检报告、医院记录和警方记录中收集。根据现有数据绘制受害者概况。
在法医管理局的宰因霍姆停尸房,对1858例尸检病例中所有18岁及以上女性死亡情况进行了为期两年的回顾性审查。最常见的死亡方式是他杀。他杀案件中最常见的死亡原因是锐器创伤。自然死亡是最不常见的死亡方式,缺血性心脏病是最常见的死因。高处坠落是自杀相关死亡最常见的方式。在中毒案件中,杀虫剂和一氧化碳是最常检测到的毒物。根据死因(创伤),钝器创伤最为常见。高处坠落占该组病例的最大比例。
头部和颈部受到钝器伤的30岁左右女性占成年女性尸检的大多数。他杀是女性死亡最常见的方式,主要是在家庭争吵后,行凶者多为配偶或亲属,凶器多为锐器。意外死亡位居第二,主要原因是术后并发症。在自杀案件中,高处坠落是最常见的原因,其次是中毒。这些发现可能有助于法医病理学家和医疗保健推广者预测和预防女性死亡。此外,这强调了提高公众对我们社会中女性暴力问题规模认识的必要性。这项研究的结果表明,不仅需要强大的法律支持网络,还需要经济独立的机会、必要的教育和意识、替代性住所,以及社会、司法机构、立法机构、行政部门、男性,最重要的是女性自身态度和思维方式的转变,这样才能降低甚至预防此类死亡,特别是自杀死亡。