Han Tao, Xu Zhexue, Liu Chunyan, Li Siran, Song Penghui, Huang Qian, Zhou Qilin, Lin Yicong, Wang Yuping
Department of Neurology, Xuanwu Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
Department of Neurology, Xuanwu Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
J Neurosci Methods. 2019 Aug 1;324:108308. doi: 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2019.05.017. Epub 2019 Jun 7.
Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) and repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) can modulate cortical excitability. However, the combining effect of tDCS and rTMS at the same motor cortex is unknown.
We have recently developed a new stimulation protocol that simultaneously combines two well-documented methods. Eleven right-handed healthy subjects undertook four sessions at the left cortical representation area of right first dorsal interosseous muscle in randomized order, the order was counter balanced. Session one was the sham control without tDCS or rTMS. Session two involved cathodal tDCS with sham rTMS. Session three involved rTMS with sham tDCS. Session four was the combination of cathodal tDCS and rTMS(tDCS-rTMS). Cathodal tDCS was applied at 1 mA, and 1200 rTMS pulses were applied at 1 Hz with 90% resting motor threshold (RMT). All stimulation durations lasted for 20 min. RMT was monitored pre- and post-stimulation immediately after finishing the stimulation. Single pulse TMS induced MEP amplitudes were monitored before and after stimulation for 30 min afterwards.
Neither stimulus modality changed the value of RMT. As compared to sham stimulation, MEP amplitudes decreased in other three conditions. MEP amplitudes in tDCS-rTMS were much more inhibited than either tDCS or rTMS alone.
We could reproduce inhibitory effect of 1 mA cathodal tDCS and 1 Hz rTMS in concordance with previous literature. The novel simultaneous tDCS-rTMS stimulation protocol can induce enhanced excitability change than either tDCS or rTMS.
Simultaneous application of cathodal tDCS with low frequency rTMS produces a stronger inhibitory effect.
经颅直流电刺激(tDCS)和重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)可调节皮质兴奋性。然而,tDCS和rTMS在同一运动皮质的联合效应尚不清楚。
我们最近开发了一种新的刺激方案,该方案同时结合了两种已被充分证明的方法。11名右利手健康受试者在右侧第一背侧骨间肌的左侧皮质代表区进行了4次实验,实验顺序随机,且顺序相互平衡。实验一为假刺激对照,不进行tDCS或rTMS。实验二为阴极tDCS加假rTMS。实验三为rTMS加假tDCS。实验四为阴极tDCS与rTMS联合(tDCS-rTMS)。阴极tDCS以1毫安的电流施加,1200个rTMS脉冲以1赫兹的频率、90%的静息运动阈值(RMT)施加。所有刺激持续时间均为20分钟。在刺激结束后立即在刺激前后监测RMT。在刺激前和刺激后30分钟监测单脉冲TMS诱发的运动诱发电位(MEP)幅度。
两种刺激方式均未改变RMT值。与假刺激相比,其他三种情况下MEP幅度均降低。tDCS-rTMS条件下的MEP幅度比单独的tDCS或rTMS受到的抑制作用更强。
我们能够重现1毫安阴极tDCS和1赫兹rTMS的抑制作用,这与先前的文献一致。新颖的同步tDCS-rTMS刺激方案可诱导比单独的tDCS或rTMS更强的兴奋性变化。
阴极tDCS与低频rTMS同时应用可产生更强的抑制作用。