Winans Nathan J, Liang Justine J, Ashcroft Bradley, Doyle Stephen, Fry Adam, Fiore Susan M, Mofakham Sima, Mikell Charles B
1Department of Neurological Surgery, Stony Brook University School of Medicine, Stony Brook, New York.
2Department of Emergency Medicine, Christiana Care Health System, Newark, Delaware; and.
J Neurosurg. 2019 Jun 14;133(2):477-485. doi: 10.3171/2019.2.JNS183568. Print 2020 Aug 1.
Severe traumatic brain injury (sTBI) carries significant morbidity and mortality. It remains difficult to counsel families on functional prognosis and plan research initiatives aimed at treating traumatic coma. In order to better address these problems, the authors set out to develop statistical models using retrospective data to identify admission characteristics that correlate with time until the return of consciousness, defined as the time to follow commands (TFC). These results were then used to create a TFC score, allowing for rapid identification of patients with predicted prolonged TFC.
Data were reviewed and collected from medical records of sTBI patients with Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) motor subscores ≤ 5 who were admitted to Stony Brook University Hospital from January 2011 to July 2018. Data were used to calculate descriptive statistics and build binary logistic regression models to identify admission characteristics that correlated with in-hospital mortality and in-hospital command-following. A Cox proportional hazards model was used to identify admission characteristics that correlated with the length of TFC. A TFC score was developed using the significant variables identified in the Cox regression model.
There were 402 adult patients who met the inclusion criteria for this study. The average age was 50.5 years, and 122 (30.3%) patients were women. In-hospital mortality was associated with older age, higher Injury Severity Score (ISS), higher Rotterdam score (head CT grading system), and the presence of bilateral fixed and dilated pupils (p < 0.01). In-hospital command-following was anticorrelated with age, ISS, Rotterdam score, and the presence of a single fixed and dilated pupil (p < 0.05). TFC was anticorrelated with age, ISS, Rotterdam score, and the presence of a single fixed and dilated pupil. Additionally, patients who sustained injuries from falls from standing height had a shorter average TFC. The 3 significant variables from the Cox regression model that explained the most variance were used to create a 4-point TFC score. The most significant of these characteristics were Rotterdam head CT scores, high impact traumas, and the presence of a single fixed and dilated pupil. Importantly, the presence of a single fixed and dilated pupil was correlated with longer TFC but no increase in likelihood of in-hospital mortality.
The creation of the 4-point TFC score will allow clinicians to quickly identify patients with predicted prolonged TFC and estimate the likelihood of command-following at different times after injury. Discussions with family members should take into account the likelihood that patients will return to consciousness and survive after TBI.
重度创伤性脑损伤(sTBI)具有较高的发病率和死亡率。目前仍难以向家属提供有关功能预后的咨询,也难以规划旨在治疗创伤性昏迷的研究项目。为了更好地解决这些问题,作者着手利用回顾性数据开发统计模型,以确定与意识恢复时间(定义为能听从指令的时间,即TFC)相关的入院特征。然后利用这些结果创建一个TFC评分,以便快速识别预计TFC延长的患者。
回顾并收集了2011年1月至2018年7月入住石溪大学医院、格拉斯哥昏迷量表(GCS)运动亚评分≤5的sTBI患者的病历数据。这些数据用于计算描述性统计量,并建立二元逻辑回归模型,以确定与院内死亡率和院内听从指令情况相关的入院特征。使用Cox比例风险模型确定与TFC时长相关的入院特征。利用Cox回归模型中确定的显著变量开发了一个TFC评分。
有402名成年患者符合本研究的纳入标准。平均年龄为50.5岁,122名(30.3%)患者为女性。院内死亡率与年龄较大、损伤严重程度评分(ISS)较高、鹿特丹评分(头部CT分级系统)较高以及双侧瞳孔固定散大有关(p<0.01)。院内听从指令情况与年龄、ISS、鹿特丹评分以及单侧瞳孔固定散大呈负相关(p<0.05)。TFC与年龄、ISS、鹿特丹评分以及单侧瞳孔固定散大呈负相关。此外,从站立高度跌落受伤的患者平均TFC较短。Cox回归模型中解释变异最多的3个显著变量被用于创建一个4分的TFC评分。其中最显著的特征是鹿特丹头部CT评分、高冲击力创伤以及单侧瞳孔固定散大。重要的是,单侧瞳孔固定散大与较长的TFC相关,但院内死亡可能性并未增加。
4分TFC评分的创建将使临床医生能够快速识别预计TFC延长的患者,并估计受伤后不同时间听从指令的可能性。与家属的讨论应考虑到患者在创伤性脑损伤后恢复意识并存活的可能性。