Department of Emergency Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Technical Resources, Assistance Center and Information Exchange, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response, Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, DC.
Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2019 Dec;13(5-6):946-957. doi: 10.1017/dmp.2019.18.
The Society of Academic Emergency Medicine Disaster Medicine Interest Group, the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response - Technical Resources, Assistance Center, and Information Exchange (ASPR TRACIE) team, and the National Institutes of Health Library searched disaster medicine peer-reviewed and gray literature to identify, review, and disseminate the most important new research in this field for academics and practitioners.
MEDLINE/PubMed and Scopus databases were searched with key words. Additional gray literature and focused hand search were performed. A Level I review of titles and abstracts with inclusion criteria of disaster medicine, health care system, and disaster type concepts was performed. Eight reviewers performed Level II full-text review and formal scoring for overall quality, impact, clarity, and importance, with scoring ranging from 0 to 20. Reviewers summarized and critiqued articles scoring 16.5 and above.
Articles totaling 1176 were identified, and 347 were screened in a Level II review. Of these, 193 (56%) were Original Research, 117 (34%) Case Report or other, and 37 (11%) were Review/Meta-Analysis. The average final score after a Level II review was 11.34. Eighteen articles scored 16.5 or higher. Of the 18 articles, 9 (50%) were Case Report or other, 7 (39%) were Original Research, and 2 (11%) were Review/Meta-Analysis.
This first review highlighted the breadth of disaster medicine, including emerging infectious disease outbreaks, terror attacks, and natural disasters. We hope this review becomes an annual source of actionable, pertinent literature for the emerging field of disaster medicine.
学术急诊医学灾难医学兴趣小组、助理秘书准备和应对-技术资源、援助中心和信息交换办公室 (ASPR TRACIE) 团队以及美国国立卫生研究院图书馆搜索了灾难医学同行评议和灰色文献,以确定、审查和传播该领域对学者和从业者最重要的新研究。
使用关键词搜索 MEDLINE/PubMed 和 Scopus 数据库。进行了额外的灰色文献和重点手工搜索。对标题和摘要进行了一级审查,纳入标准为灾难医学、医疗保健系统和灾难类型概念。八名审查员对整体质量、影响、清晰度和重要性进行了二级全文审查和正式评分,评分范围为 0 到 20。评分在 16.5 及以上的文章由评论员进行总结和评价。
共确定了 1176 篇文章,并在二级审查中筛选了 347 篇。其中,193 篇(56%)为原始研究,117 篇(34%)为病例报告或其他,37 篇(11%)为综述/荟萃分析。二级审查后的平均最终得分为 11.34。18 篇文章得分为 16.5 或更高。在 18 篇文章中,9 篇(50%)为病例报告或其他,7 篇(39%)为原始研究,2 篇(11%)为综述/荟萃分析。
这是第一次审查,强调了灾难医学的广泛范围,包括新发传染病爆发、恐怖袭击和自然灾害。我们希望本综述成为灾难医学这一新兴领域的行动相关、相关文献的年度来源。